Welcome!

Enter a player name to begin or load your saved progress.

Consolidated city-county Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge

Study Hints Create Teach
Global Score: 0
Trophies: 0 🏆

‹ Back

Score: 0 / 100

Study Guide: Comparative Analysis of Consolidated City-County Governance Models

Cheat Sheet:
Comparative Analysis of Consolidated City-County Governance Models Study Guide

Foundations of City-County Consolidation: Definitions, Rationale, and Advantages

A consolidated city-county is a local government type where a city merges with its surrounding county, creating a single jurisdiction with combined powers.

Answer: True

Explanation: This definition accurately describes a consolidated city-county as a unified jurisdiction combining municipal and county governmental functions.

Return to Game

Consolidated city-county governments are typically formed to reduce government efficiency and increase the number of administrative layers.

Answer: False

Explanation: Consolidated city-county governments are generally established to enhance efficiency, potentially leading to cost savings and streamlined planning, rather than increasing administrative layers or reducing efficiency.

Return to Game

What is the primary advantage cited for forming consolidated city-county governments?

Answer: Potential cost savings through efficiency and streamlined planning.

Explanation: Consolidated city-county governments are primarily advocated for their potential to achieve cost savings through enhanced efficiency and more effective, streamlined planning processes.

Return to Game

Governmental Structures, Terminology, and Classification

Consolidated city-counties usually feature multiple independent chief executives, one for the city and one for the county.

Answer: False

Explanation: Typically, consolidated city-counties feature a single chief executive who serves as both the city mayor and the head of the county government, unifying executive leadership.

Return to Game

In Louisiana, consolidated city-counties are referred to as 'unified municipalities'.

Answer: False

Explanation: In Louisiana, the term used for jurisdictions equivalent to consolidated city-counties is 'city-parish' or 'consolidated government', not 'unified municipalities'.

Return to Game

The United States Census Bureau uses the specific local terminology, such as 'city-parish', when categorizing merged jurisdictions.

Answer: False

Explanation: The U.S. Census Bureau generically categorizes merged jurisdictions as 'consolidated cities', irrespective of the specific local or state terminology used.

Return to Game

In California, a consolidated city-county is officially designated as a 'town and county'.

Answer: False

Explanation: In California, a consolidated city-county is officially designated as a 'city and county'.

Return to Game

The US Census Bureau defines the 'balance' in a consolidated city-county as the entire consolidated government including all incorporated places within its boundaries.

Answer: False

Explanation: The 'balance' as defined by the U.S. Census Bureau refers to the portion of the consolidated government that excludes semi-independent incorporated places within its boundaries, differentiating it from the total entity.

Return to Game

A 'merged' city-county implies that the city and county are considered separate entities despite having consolidated government functions.

Answer: True

Explanation: In a 'merged' city-county structure, the city and county retain separate identities even though their governmental functions are consolidated, distinguishing it from a 'single entity' consolidation.

Return to Game

The 'balance' concept, used by the US Census Bureau, helps differentiate the core consolidated government from its component municipalities by excluding semi-independent incorporated places.

Answer: True

Explanation: The U.S. Census Bureau uses the 'balance' concept to distinguish the primary consolidated government from any remaining independent municipalities within its boundaries.

Return to Game

In Alaska, a 'city and borough' is the term used for a consolidated city-county structure.

Answer: True

Explanation: Alaska utilizes the term 'city and borough' or 'unified municipality' to denote structures equivalent to consolidated city-counties, merging city and borough functions.

Return to Game

In Louisiana, the term 'county-city' is used for consolidated jurisdictions where a city and its parish have merged.

Answer: False

Explanation: In Louisiana, the term 'city-parish' is used for consolidated jurisdictions where a city and its parish have merged, not 'county-city'.

Return to Game

How does the U.S. Census Bureau categorize merged jurisdictions like consolidated city-counties?

Answer: Generically as consolidated cities.

Explanation: The U.S. Census Bureau employs a generic classification, referring to all such merged jurisdictions as 'consolidated cities', regardless of their specific local or state designations.

Return to Game

In Louisiana, what is the term used for jurisdictions equivalent to consolidated city-counties?

Answer: City-parishes

Explanation: In Louisiana, the term 'city-parish' is used to denote jurisdictions where a city and its parish have merged their governmental operations, serving as the equivalent of a consolidated city-county.

Return to Game

Which of the following is NOT a typical governmental structure within a consolidated city-county?

Answer: Separate, independent mayors for the city and the county components.

Explanation: Consolidated city-counties typically feature a single chief executive and a unified legislative body, rather than separate mayors for city and county components.

Return to Game

What does the 'balance' refer to in the context of the US Census Bureau's statistics for consolidated cities?

Answer: The portion of the consolidated government that excludes semi-independent incorporated places within its boundaries.

Explanation: The U.S. Census Bureau defines the 'balance' as the segment of a consolidated government that does not include semi-independent incorporated places situated within its jurisdiction.

Return to Game

What is the distinction between a 'consolidated city-county' and a 'city and county' in California?

Answer: In California, a 'city and county' has city powers superseding county powers, and is counted as a county by the state.

Explanation: In California, a 'city and county' designation signifies that the city's chartered powers take precedence over county powers, and the state recognizes it as a county for specific administrative purposes.

Return to Game

What is the significance of the 'balance' concept in consolidated city-counties according to the US Census Bureau?

Answer: It helps differentiate the core consolidated government from its component municipalities.

Explanation: The 'balance' concept, as used by the U.S. Census Bureau, serves to distinguish the primary consolidated government from any constituent municipalities that retain separate administrative identities.

Return to Game

What is the difference between a consolidated city-county and a 'unified municipality' in Alaska?

Answer: Consolidated city-counties involve city and county mergers, while unified municipalities merge city and borough functions.

Explanation: The primary difference is that consolidated city-counties merge city and county entities, whereas Alaska's 'unified municipalities' (or cities and boroughs) merge city and borough functions.

Return to Game

What does the term 'city-parish' refer to in Louisiana?

Answer: A jurisdiction where a city and its parish have merged their governmental operations.

Explanation: In Louisiana, 'city-parish' denotes a jurisdiction formed by the merger of a city and its parish, functioning as a consolidated entity.

Return to Game

Formation Processes, Challenges, and Success Rates

Voter approval through referendums is often required for the formation of consolidated city-counties in the U.S., and historically, most proposals have been approved.

Answer: False

Explanation: Voter approval via referendums is frequently necessary for consolidation, but historically, a significant majority of these proposals have been rejected by voters, indicating a low success rate.

Return to Game

Voter resistance and complex local dynamics are not considered significant factors contributing to the lower success rate of city-county consolidation proposals in the U.S.

Answer: False

Explanation: Voter resistance and intricate local political dynamics are indeed significant factors contributing to the historically lower success rates of city-county consolidation proposals in the U.S.

Return to Game

Case Studies: Consolidated Governments in the United States

Excluding Hawaii, the Midwest and Upper South regions of the U.S. have the highest concentration of large consolidated city-county governments.

Answer: True

Explanation: Data indicates that, excluding Hawaii, the Midwest and Upper South regions of the United States exhibit the highest prevalence of large consolidated city-county governments.

Return to Game

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, is the largest consolidated city-county by land area in the United States.

Answer: False

Explanation: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, is the largest consolidated city-county by population. Sitka, Alaska, is the largest by land area.

Return to Game

The City and County of San Francisco was formed by consolidating the city with the entirety of the original San Francisco County in 1856.

Answer: False

Explanation: In 1856, San Francisco County was split; the northern portion consolidated with the City of San Francisco, while the remainder formed the new San Mateo County.

Return to Game

The City and County of Broomfield, Colorado, was established in 2001 by consolidating territory from three counties: Adams, Jefferson, and Weld.

Answer: False

Explanation: The City and County of Broomfield was established in 2001 by consolidating territory from portions of four counties: Boulder, Adams, Jefferson, and Weld.

Return to Game

Denver became the City and County of Denver and separated from Arapahoe County in 1902.

Answer: True

Explanation: Denver was incorporated as the City and County of Denver in 1902, separating from Arapahoe County and becoming coterminous with a newly defined county.

Return to Game

Nantucket, Massachusetts, is considered a consolidated city-county because it merged its city government with Nantucket County.

Answer: False

Explanation: Nantucket is considered a 'Town and County' because the town and county have been identical entities since its separation from New York and incorporation into Massachusetts, not through a merger of separate city and county governments.

Return to Game

In Georgia, Columbus merged with Muscogee County, and Macon merged with Bibb County to form single consolidated entities.

Answer: True

Explanation: Columbus's consolidation with Muscogee County and Macon's with Bibb County are prominent examples of city-county mergers in Georgia.

Return to Game

Jacksonville, Florida, consolidated with Duval County, and no other incorporated places retain separate governments within its boundaries.

Answer: False

Explanation: While Jacksonville consolidated with Duval County, four incorporated places within its boundaries—Jacksonville Beach, Neptune Beach, Atlantic Beach, and the town of Baldwin—retain separate governments.

Return to Game

The Municipality of Anchorage, Alaska, is an example of a consolidated city-borough, merging city and borough functions.

Answer: True

Explanation: The Municipality of Anchorage exemplifies a consolidated city-borough structure, integrating the governmental powers of a city and a borough.

Return to Game

Consolidations in Virginia, such as Chesapeake and Hampton, result in independent cities, which are distinct from the definition of consolidated city-counties.

Answer: True

Explanation: In Virginia, city-county consolidations often result in independent cities, which are classified differently under state law than typical consolidated city-counties.

Return to Game

When Carson City consolidated with Ormsby County, Nevada, the county government continued to operate separately.

Answer: False

Explanation: Upon consolidation with Carson City in 1969, Ormsby County was simultaneously dissolved, making Carson City an independent municipality.

Return to Game

New York City's five boroughs are coterminous with counties, and the city government exercises unified control, but county-level government functions separately for each borough.

Answer: False

Explanation: While New York City's boroughs are coterminous with counties and the city government is unified, county-level government functions are largely non-existent as separate entities.

Return to Game

Albuquerque and Bernalillo County, New Mexico, considered consolidation in 1959 and again in 2003.

Answer: True

Explanation: Discussions regarding the consolidation of Albuquerque and Bernalillo County, New Mexico, occurred in 1959 and were revisited in 2003.

Return to Game

A proposal to merge Baltimore City and Baltimore County in Maryland was successfully passed in 1999.

Answer: False

Explanation: A proposed constitutional amendment to merge Baltimore City and Baltimore County in Maryland was introduced in 1999 but was withdrawn; consolidation has not been successfully passed.

Return to Game

Evansville and Vanderburgh County, Indiana, have voted on consolidation only once, in 2002.

Answer: False

Explanation: Evansville and Vanderburgh County, Indiana, have considered consolidation multiple times, including votes in 1959, 1974, 2002, and 2012.

Return to Game

Consolidation efforts for Omaha and Douglas County, Nebraska, have been consistently successful, with proposals approved by both city and county boards.

Answer: False

Explanation: Consolidation efforts for Omaha and Douglas County, Nebraska, have faced challenges, with recent proposals being rejected by either the city council or the state legislature.

Return to Game

The independent City of St. Louis, Missouri, is part of St. Louis County, despite seceding in the 1870s.

Answer: False

Explanation: The independent City of St. Louis seceded from St. Louis County in the 1870s and is not part of it; subsequent reunification proposals have been rejected by voters.

Return to Game

Tallahassee and Leon County, Florida, have considered consolidation multiple times, including in the 1970s and 1990s.

Answer: True

Explanation: Tallahassee and Leon County, Florida, have engaged in multiple discussions and proposals for consolidation, notably in the 1970s and 1990s.

Return to Game

Pittsburgh and Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, saw consolidation referendums pass in the early 20th century but were blocked by the state assembly.

Answer: True

Explanation: Referendums supporting consolidation for Pittsburgh and Allegheny County passed in the early 20th century but were ultimately obstructed by the state assembly.

Return to Game

In California, a 'city and county' designation means the county powers are superior to the city's chartered powers.

Answer: False

Explanation: In California's 'city and county' structure, the city's chartered powers supersede the county's chartered powers, and the state counts it as a county for certain administrative purposes.

Return to Game

Knoxville and Knox County, Tennessee, have considered consolidation proposals in 1959, 1978, and 1996.

Answer: True

Explanation: Knoxville and Knox County, Tennessee, have undergone multiple consolidation considerations, with proposals emerging in 1959, 1978, and 1996.

Return to Game

The Bronx separated from New York County in 1914 to form its own county, solidifying the five borough-county structure of New York City.

Answer: True

Explanation: The Bronx separated from New York County in 1914, establishing its own county and reinforcing the structure where each of New York City's five boroughs is coterminous with a county.

Return to Game

Boston managed county functions for Suffolk County until 1999, but this represented a full consolidation of all municipalities within the county.

Answer: False

Explanation: Boston managed county functions for Suffolk County until 1999, but this arrangement did not constitute a full consolidation, as other municipalities within the county remained separate.

Return to Game

Which U.S. region, excluding Hawaii, has the highest concentration of large consolidated city-county governments?

Answer: The Midwest and the Upper South.

Explanation: Excluding Hawaii, the regions with the highest prevalence of large consolidated city-county governments are the Midwest and the Upper South.

Return to Game

What is the largest consolidated city-county in the United States by population?

Answer: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Explanation: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, holds the distinction of being the most populous consolidated city-county in the United States.

Return to Game

What historical event led to the formation of the City and County of San Francisco?

Answer: The split of San Francisco County in 1856, consolidating the northern part into the City and County of San Francisco.

Explanation: The City and County of San Francisco was formed in 1856 through the division of San Francisco County, with the northern portion consolidating with the city.

Return to Game

How did Denver become the City and County of Denver?

Answer: It separated from Arapahoe County and became coterminous with a newly defined county in 1902.

Explanation: Denver achieved its status as the City and County of Denver in 1902 when it separated from Arapahoe County and became coterminous with a newly established county.

Return to Game

In Virginia, what is the outcome of city-county consolidations like Chesapeake and Hampton?

Answer: They result in independent cities, not consolidated city-counties per the Code of Virginia.

Explanation: Consolidations in Virginia, such as those involving Chesapeake and Hampton, typically result in the formation of independent cities, which are distinct from the classification of consolidated city-counties under Virginia law.

Return to Game

What happened to Ormsby County, Nevada, when it consolidated with Carson City in 1969?

Answer: Ormsby County was dissolved, and Carson City became independent of county structure.

Explanation: Upon its consolidation with Carson City in 1969, Ormsby County was dissolved, resulting in Carson City's status as a municipality independent of any county structure.

Return to Game

What is the historical relationship between Boston and Suffolk County, Massachusetts, regarding consolidation?

Answer: Boston managed county functions until 1999, but this was not a full consolidation as other municipalities remained separate.

Explanation: Boston managed Suffolk County's functions until 1999, but this arrangement did not represent a complete consolidation, as other municipalities within the county maintained separate governmental structures.

Return to Game

What is the status of consolidation proposals for Knoxville and Knox County, Tennessee?

Answer: They have considered consolidation on several occasions, including in 1959, 1978, and 1996.

Explanation: Knoxville and Knox County, Tennessee, have explored consolidation multiple times, with proposals dating back to 1959, 1978, and 1996.

Return to Game

What is the historical relationship between New York City's boroughs and counties?

Answer: The five boroughs are coterminous with counties, and while the city government is unified, county-level government is largely non-existent as a separate entity.

Explanation: New York City's five boroughs are coterminous with counties; while the city government is unified, separate county-level governmental functions are largely absent.

Return to Game

International Perspectives on Consolidated Governance

The six metropolitan counties in England created in 1974, such as Greater Manchester and Merseyside, still operate with their own county councils today.

Answer: False

Explanation: The metropolitan county councils in England, established in 1974, were abolished in 1986. Certain functions are now managed by joint boards.

Return to Game

Berlin and Hamburg in Germany function solely as cities, with no state-level administrative powers.

Answer: False

Explanation: Berlin and Hamburg are unique in Germany as they function as both cities and states, possessing state-level administrative powers.

Return to Game

Paris, France, has been coterminous with the department of Paris since 1968, integrating municipal and departmental roles.

Answer: True

Explanation: Since 1968, Paris has been coterminous with the department of Paris, effectively merging its municipal and departmental administrative functions.

Return to Game

In Russia, 'urban districts' are territories that combine a city with nearby settlements under a single mayor's office.

Answer: True

Explanation: Russian 'urban districts' are administrative divisions that integrate a city with adjacent settlements under a unified mayoral administration.

Return to Game

Single-tier municipalities in Ontario, Canada, like Toronto, are functionally similar to American consolidated city-counties, but the county always continues to exist alongside the new municipality.

Answer: False

Explanation: While functionally similar, single-tier municipalities in Ontario, such as Toronto, differ from many U.S. consolidated city-counties because the original county or region ceases to exist upon amalgamation.

Return to Game

Tokyo, Japan, functions as a single city government, having amalgamated the City of Tokyo with the surrounding prefecture.

Answer: False

Explanation: Tokyo functions as a metropolis, formed by the amalgamation of the City of Tokyo and Tokyo Prefecture. It comprises a central government and 23 special wards that operate as cities, creating a complex structure rather than a single city government.

Return to Game

The Australian Capital Territory (ACT) integrates city and territory governance by having the territorial government directly perform all municipal functions for Canberra, eliminating the need for separate Local Government Areas (LGAs).

Answer: True

Explanation: The ACT is unique in Australia as its territorial government directly performs municipal functions for Canberra, bypassing the need for separate Local Government Areas.

Return to Game

Tokyo Metropolis functions primarily as a single, unified city government, similar to a consolidated city-county.

Answer: False

Explanation: Tokyo Metropolis operates as a prefecture with a central government and 23 special wards functioning as cities, a structure more complex than a typical consolidated city-county.

Return to Game

In South Korea, Seoul is designated as a metropolitan city, while Busan and Daegu are classified as special cities.

Answer: False

Explanation: In South Korea, Seoul is designated as a special city, while Busan and Daegu are classified as metropolitan cities.

Return to Game

The Australian Capital Territory (ACT) differs from most Australian Local Government Areas (LGAs) because the territorial government directly performs municipal functions for Canberra.

Answer: True

Explanation: The ACT is distinct from typical Australian LGAs as its territorial government directly manages all municipal responsibilities for Canberra.

Return to Game

The six metropolitan counties in England created in 1974 were abolished entirely in 1986.

Answer: False

Explanation: While the metropolitan county councils were abolished in 1986, joint boards were established to manage certain functions, meaning the counties were not entirely abolished without replacement.

Return to Game

How does the governmental structure of Paris, France, relate to its department?

Answer: Paris functions as both a city and a department, coterminous since 1968.

Explanation: Since 1968, Paris has been coterminous with the department of Paris, integrating its municipal and departmental administrative roles into a singular governmental structure.

Return to Game

What is the status of the six metropolitan counties in England created in 1974?

Answer: They no longer have county councils, with joint boards managing certain functions since 1986.

Explanation: The metropolitan county councils established in England in 1974 were abolished in 1986; however, joint boards were instituted to oversee specific functions.

Return to Game

Which of the following is true about the Australian Capital Territory (ACT)?

Answer: The territorial government directly performs all municipal functions for Canberra.

Explanation: The Australian Capital Territory (ACT) is unique in that its territorial government directly manages all municipal functions for Canberra, unlike most Australian states which utilize separate Local Government Areas.

Return to Game

What is the governmental structure of Tokyo, Japan?

Answer: A prefecture formed by amalgamating the City of Tokyo and Tokyo Prefecture, with a central government and 23 special wards functioning as cities.

Explanation: Tokyo operates as a metropolis, established by the amalgamation of the City of Tokyo and Tokyo Prefecture. It features a central government and 23 special wards that function autonomously as cities.

Return to Game

What is the governmental structure of Tokyo Metropolis?

Answer: It functions as a prefecture with a central government and 23 special wards acting as cities.

Explanation: Tokyo Metropolis functions as a prefecture, featuring a central government and 23 special wards that operate with city-like autonomy.

Return to Game

What is the governmental structure of Paris in relation to its department in France?

Answer: Paris functions as both a city and a department, coterminous since 1968.

Explanation: Since 1968, Paris has been coterminous with the department of Paris, integrating its municipal and departmental administrative functions.

Return to Game

What is the status of the six metropolitan counties in England created in 1974 regarding their county councils?

Answer: They no longer have county councils, with joint boards managing certain functions since 1986.

Explanation: The metropolitan county councils in England, established in 1974, were abolished in 1986; however, joint boards were subsequently formed to manage specific functions.

Return to Game