What is the fundamental principle of a balanced budget amendment or debt brake?

A balanced budget amendment, also referred to as a debt brake, is a constitutional rule designed to ensure that a state's expenditures do not surpass its income. This requires a balance between the government's projected revenues and its planned expenditures, either on an annual basis or over a multi-year period.

Which nations have constitutionally mandated balanced budget provisions?

Several countries have incorporated balanced-budget provisions into their constitutions, including Germany, Hong Kong, Italy, Poland, Slovenia, Spain, and Switzerland, among others.

What is the prevalence of balanced budget requirements among U.S. states?

With the exception of Vermont, all U.S. states have implemented some form of balanced budget provision that governs their operating budgets, although the specific details of these provisions vary from state to state.

Does the U.S. Constitution currently mandate a balanced budget for the federal government?

No, the United States Constitution does not currently contain a provision requiring the federal government to maintain a balanced budget.

What are the primary arguments supporting the adoption of balanced budget amendments?

Supporters of balanced budget amendments argue that they foster greater fiscal discipline by reducing deficit spending and constraining politicians from making irresponsible short-term spending decisions.

What economic concerns do economists typically raise regarding strict annual balanced budget amendments?

Economists generally express concern that strict annual balanced budget amendments can have detrimental effects on the economy in the short term. They note that deficit spending can be beneficial during recessions, and that government spending cuts during such periods can exacerbate and prolong economic downturns.

How do most balanced budget provisions accommodate economic downturns or emergencies?

To mitigate the negative economic impacts, most balanced budget provisions include exceptions for situations like war, national emergencies, or recessions. Alternatively, they may allow the legislature to suspend the rule if a supermajority of votes is secured.

When did Germany constitutionally implement its 'debt brake' (Schuldenbremse)?

Germany amended its constitution in 2009 to introduce the Schuldenbremse, or 'debt brake,' which is a balanced budget provision applicable to both the federal government and its constituent states (Länder).

What specific fiscal limits does Germany's debt brake impose?

Since 2016, Germany's federal government is prohibited from running a structural deficit exceeding 0.35% of its Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Since 2020, German states are not permitted to run any structural deficit at all.

In what ways has Germany utilized off-budget mechanisms in relation to its debt brake?

The German federal government has employed off-budget funds, known as Sondervermögen, as a means to circumvent the limitations imposed by the debt brake rule.

What has been Austria's experience in attempting to establish a debt brake?

Austria made attempts to amend its constitution to introduce a debt brake in November 2011 and again in October 2019. However, both efforts were unsuccessful due to a failure to gain the required two-thirds majority support in parliament.

What constitutional change did France enact concerning public sector finances in 2008?

In 2008, France amended Article 34 of its Constitution to include the objective of balancing public sector accounts. Additionally, it established the independent High Council of Public Finances to assess the sustainability and adherence to planned targets of public spending.

When did Italy incorporate a balanced budget amendment into its constitution, and what has been its practical effect?

Italy added a balanced budget amendment to its Constitution in 2012. While the amendment permits deficit spending during emergencies with parliamentary approval, the definition of 'emergency' has been broadly interpreted, and Italy has not yet achieved a balanced budget since the amendment's adoption.

What is the public debt limit established by Poland's constitution?

Poland's constitution, adopted in 1997, sets a limit on public debt at 60% of GDP. To ensure this limit is not breached, Poland maintains a self-imposed threshold of 55% of GDP, at which point the government must take measures to balance the budget.

What fiscal requirements were introduced in Spain through its 2011 constitutional amendment?

Spain's 2011 constitutional amendment mandates a balanced budget at both national and regional levels by 2020. It also stipulates that public debt should not exceed 60% of GDP, allows for exceptions in cases of natural catastrophe or economic recession, and requires adherence to the European Union's annual deficit limit of 3% of GDP.

What are Sweden's fiscal targets concerning budget surpluses and national debt?

Sweden's government is required to maintain a budget surplus of at least 1% of GDP on average over a business cycle, with national debt not exceeding 35% of GDP. This framework applies to all levels of government, including local authorities.

When did Switzerland adopt its debt brake, and how does its mechanism function?

Switzerland adopted the debt brake as a constitutional amendment in 2001, with implementation beginning in 2003. The rule requires the budget to be balanced each year, adjusted for economic conditions. This adjustment involves multiplying expenditures by a cyclical factor, allowing for deficits during recessions and requiring surpluses during economic booms to achieve structural balance over a business cycle.

Which U.S. state is an exception regarding balanced budget provisions?

Vermont is the only U.S. state that does not have a balanced budget provision applicable to its operating budget.

What is the unique fiscal rule implemented in Oregon known as the 'Oregon kicker'?

The 'Oregon kicker' is a fiscal measure that requires any state budget surplus exceeding 2% of revenue to be refunded to taxpayers, thereby preventing the accumulation of large surpluses.

When was the U.S. federal government last free of debt?

The United States federal government has maintained a national debt since its inception, with the exception of a brief period during President Andrew Jackson's administration.

What was Thomas Jefferson's perspective on the federal government's borrowing authority?

Thomas Jefferson advocated for a constitutional amendment to eliminate the federal government's power to borrow money, believing it would improve governance. However, his purchase of the Louisiana Territory involved borrowing, suggesting a potential shift in his stance or a recognition of practical necessities.

What does Section 4 of the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution state regarding public debt?

Section 4 of the Fourteenth Amendment affirms that the validity of the United States' public debt, including debts incurred for suppressing insurrection, shall not be questioned. It also voids any debt or obligation incurred in aid of rebellion against the United States.

Who proposed one of the earliest balanced budget amendment initiatives in the U.S. Congress, and what were its key features?

Senator Millard Tydings introduced one of the earliest proposals, Senate Joint Resolution 36. This resolution aimed to amend the Constitution by prohibiting appropriations that exceeded revenues without new debt authorization and requiring the liquidation of any new debt over a 15-year period.

What was the focus of Representative Harold Knutson's 1936 proposed constitutional amendment regarding the federal debt?

In 1936, Representative Harold Knutson proposed House Joint Resolution 579, which sought a constitutional amendment to establish a per capita limit on the federal debt during peacetime.

Under Article V of the U.S. Constitution, what process allows states to initiate constitutional amendments?

Article V of the U.S. Constitution permits states to propose constitutional amendments if two-thirds of the state legislatures formally request Congress to convene an amendment-proposing convention.

How many U.S. states had applied for a convention to propose a balanced budget amendment by late 2016?

By December 27, 2016, 28 states had outstanding applications for a convention to propose a balanced budget amendment. Wyoming became the 29th state to issue such a call in February 2017.

What fiscal policy did the Nixon administration pursue regarding the federal budget?

The Nixon administration prioritized combating inflation over maintaining a balanced budget, leading to the accumulation of deficits during periods of mild recession. President Nixon famously remarked, 'We are all Keynesians now,' reflecting this approach.

What economic condition characterized the Jimmy Carter presidency, and how did it influence the balanced budget debate?

The Jimmy Carter presidency was associated with 'stagflation,' a combination of economic stagnation and rising inflation. This economic climate fueled calls from Republicans for a Balanced Budget Amendment as a potential remedy.

What was Governor Jerry Brown's stance on the balanced budget amendment during the 1980 presidential election?

During the 1980 presidential election, Governor Jerry Brown was among the liberal Democrats who began advocating for a Balanced Budget Amendment.

What was the outcome of the U.S. Senate's vote on a balanced budget amendment in August 1982?

In August 1982, the U.S. Senate passed Joint Resolution 58, a proposed balanced budget amendment. However, the measure failed in the House of Representatives, falling short of the necessary two-thirds majority by 46 votes.

What strategy did proponents of a balanced budget amendment pursue after the 1982 House defeat?

Following the defeat in the House, amendment proponents initiated a strategy to bypass Congress by leveraging Article V of the Constitution, aiming to gather petitions from two-thirds of state legislatures to call for a constitutional convention.

What was the purpose of the Gramm-Rudman-Hollings Act of 1985?

The Gramm-Rudman-Hollings Act was enacted in 1985 to mandate automatic cuts in discretionary spending if deficit-reduction targets were not met, partly in response to the growing movement for a state-initiated constitutional convention.

What key issue did Ross Perot emphasize during his 1992 presidential campaign?

Ross Perot made the federal deficit and his proposals for its elimination a central theme of his 1992 presidential campaign, alongside his protectionist trade policies.

Did the Clinton administration achieve budget surpluses, and if so, during which fiscal years?

Yes, the Clinton administration reported annual budget surpluses from Fiscal Year 1998 through Fiscal Year 2001, accumulating a total surplus of $419 billion over those four years.

What criticism has been leveled against the budget surpluses reported during the Clinton administration?

Critics argued that the reported surpluses were limited to 'on-budget' accounts and did not reflect a reduction in the overall national debt, as increased tax revenues were borrowed from intragovernmental funds like the Social Security Trust Fund.

What fiscal conflict occurred between Congress and President Clinton in 1995 concerning the budget?

In 1995, a significant budget dispute arose between the Republican-controlled Congress and President Clinton over spending cuts. This conflict led to a presidential veto of the budget and a brief federal government shutdown. During this period, a balanced-budget amendment passed the House but narrowly failed to pass the Senate.

What role did Newt Gingrich play in the push for a balanced budget amendment in the 1990s?

Newt Gingrich was a principal architect of the 'Contract with America,' which included a commitment to a balanced-budget amendment. As Speaker of the House, he played a key role in the House's passage of such an amendment in 1995.

What factors contributed to the return of U.S. budget deficits after the surpluses of the late 1990s?

A combination of factors, including a recession, tax cuts, and increased government spending (particularly on military operations), led to the reversal of the late 1990s budget surpluses and a subsequent rise in deficits and the national debt.

How did the gross U.S. federal debt and its percentage of GDP change during George W. Bush's presidency?

During George W. Bush's presidency, from January 2001 to December 2008, the gross federal debt increased from $5.7 trillion to $10.7 trillion. As a percentage of GDP, it rose from 57.0% to 74.5%.

What impact did the Great Recession have on the U.S. budget deficit and national debt?

The Great Recession significantly impacted the U.S. budget by reducing tax revenues and increasing government stimulus spending. This led to a rapidly escalating deficit, with the national debt reaching a record $11.9 trillion by the end of 2009.

How was a balanced budget amendment linked to the U.S. debt ceiling crisis in 2011?

During the 2011 debt ceiling crisis, some Republican proposals sought to tie increases in the debt ceiling to the approval of a balanced budget amendment. These proposals often included provisions to limit federal spending relative to GDP and require a supermajority vote for tax increases.

What was the outcome of the U.S. House of Representatives vote on a balanced budget amendment in November 2011?

In November 2011, the House of Representatives voted against a balanced budget amendment. Some lawmakers, like David Dreier, who had previously supported such amendments, indicated a change in their position, citing the budget balancing achievements of the late 1990s.

What is the general consensus among economists regarding the economic impact of strict annual balanced budget amendments?

Economists largely agree that strict annual balanced budget amendments can have adverse economic consequences. They emphasize that deficit spending can be beneficial during economic downturns, and that cutting spending in such times can worsen recessions.

What did economists surveyed by the American Economic Association agree upon regarding the timing of budget balancing?

In a 2003 survey, approximately 90% of economists surveyed by the American Economic Association agreed that budget balancing should occur over the course of the business cycle, rather than on a strict yearly basis.

What were the findings of the IGM Chicago survey in 2017 concerning balanced budget amendments?

In 2017, economists surveyed by IGM Chicago largely agreed that a balanced budget amendment would not reduce the variability of economic output in the United States. Furthermore, 53% of the surveyed economists believed it would not significantly lower the federal government's borrowing costs.

Who are some notable advocates or organizations that support balanced budget amendments?

Prominent advocates include economist James M. Buchanan. Organizations supporting balanced budget amendments include the Balanced Budget Amendment Task Force, the American Legislative Exchange Council, and Citizens for Self-Governance.

How is the balanced budget amendment sometimes characterized in political discourse?

The balanced budget amendment is sometimes criticized as 'political posturing' because proponents may advocate for it without specifying the potentially unpopular tax increases or spending cuts needed to achieve fiscal balance. Some critics describe it as an 'avoidance device'.

What argument does Dean Baker present regarding the relationship between U.S. trade deficits and federal budget deficits?

Dean Baker argues that unless the U.S. dollar significantly devalues, the federal government must run budget deficits to offset trade deficits. Otherwise, he contends, the economy would likely shrink, leading to increased unemployment.

What are some potential challenges to the enforceability of a balanced budget amendment?

Potential enforceability issues include the reliance on budget projections, the possibility of circumventing the rule through inflated revenue forecasts or off-budget spending, and the risk that Congress might declare a perpetual state of war to avoid compliance with deficit limits.

What does the Basic Law of Hong Kong stipulate regarding government budgets?

The Basic Law of Hong Kong mandates that the government must ensure its expenditures remain within the limits of its revenues when preparing the budget and must avoid deficits.

What data does the table titled 'Additions to U.S. public debt from FY1994 to FY2012' present?

This table provides data on the annual deficit, deficit as a percentage of GDP, total public debt, and total debt as a percentage of GDP for the U.S. federal government from fiscal year 1994 through fiscal year 2012.

Balanced Budget Amendment Wiki: The Fiscal Mandate: Navigating Balanced Budgets

Dive in with Flashcard Learning!

When you are ready...
🎮 Play the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge Game🎮

Understanding the Balanced Budget Amendment

Core Principle

A balanced budget amendment is a constitutional rule mandating that a state's expenditures must not exceed its revenues. This principle aims to enforce fiscal discipline by requiring governments to balance their budgets, either on an annual basis or over a defined multi-year period.

Constitutional Framework

Such provisions are embedded within the fundamental law of a nation or state, providing a legal and structural constraint on governmental fiscal policy. They serve as a mechanism to limit deficit spending and manage national debt.

Global Adoption

Numerous countries, including Germany, Italy, Spain, Poland, Switzerland, and Hong Kong, have incorporated balanced budget requirements into their constitutions or fiscal frameworks. In the United States, most states adhere to similar provisions for their operating budgets.

International Perspectives

Germany: The "Schuldenbremse"

Germany's constitutional amendment, the Schuldenbremse ("debt brake"), introduced in 2009, limits structural deficits for the federal government and states. While promoting fiscal prudence, it has faced criticism for its rigidity and potential to hinder counter-cyclical policy responses.

Spain: Constitutional Reform

In 2011, Spain amended its constitution to require a balanced budget by 2020, with a public debt limit of 60% of GDP. Exceptions are permitted for emergencies, but the practical application has seen ongoing parliamentary authorization for borrowing.

Switzerland: Cyclical Adjustment

Switzerland's debt brake, adopted in 2001, mandates structural balance adjusted for economic conditions. This approach allows for deficits during recessions and requires surpluses during economic booms, aiming for stability over the business cycle.

Hong Kong: Basic Law Mandate

The Hong Kong Basic Law stipulates that the government must keep expenditures within revenues when drawing up its budget and avoid deficits, reflecting a commitment to fiscal prudence in its financial management.

The United States Context

State-Level Provisions

Nearly all U.S. states, with the exception of Vermont, have constitutional or statutory requirements for balanced operating budgets. These provisions vary in strictness and enforcement mechanisms, often allowing for capital budget financing through debt.

Federal Proposals and History

The U.S. Constitution does not mandate a balanced budget at the federal level. Numerous proposals for a federal balanced budget amendment have been introduced, often requiring a supermajority vote to waive the requirement during emergencies like war or recession. The movement gained significant traction in the late 20th century and continues to be a subject of political debate.

Debt Trends

The U.S. federal government has historically operated with significant debt. Data from 1910 to 2012 illustrates substantial fluctuations in gross debt as a percentage of GDP, influenced by economic conditions, wars, and fiscal policies.

Selected U.S. Federal Debt and GDP Data:

Fiscal Year	Gross Debt ($ Billions)	% of GDP
1910	2.653	8.0%
1920	25.95	29.2%
1930	16.19	16.6%
1940	42.97	44.4%
1950	257.3	91.2%
1960	286.3	54.6%
1970	370.9	36.2%
1980	907.7	33.4%
1990	3,233	56.0%
2000	5,674	57.4%
2008	10,025	69.2%
2012	16,300	~104%

Note: Data is illustrative and may vary based on source and calculation methods.

Historical Trajectory

Early Concepts

The idea of fiscal constraint dates back to the early days of the United States, with figures like Thomas Jefferson advocating for limitations on government borrowing. Early constitutional frameworks and subsequent amendments, like the Fourteenth Amendment, addressed the validity of public debt.

Mid-to-Late 20th Century

The post-war era saw periods of deficit spending, notably under President Nixon. Concerns over inflation and deficits in the 1970s and 1980s fueled support for balanced budget amendments. Legislative efforts like the Gramm-Rudman-Hollings Act attempted fiscal controls, though often with limited success.

The Clinton Era and Beyond

The 1990s saw federal budget surpluses, attributed partly to fiscal policy and economic growth. However, subsequent tax cuts and increased spending, particularly following the 2008 recession, led to renewed debates and escalating deficits, reigniting calls for constitutional amendments.

Economic and Political Debate

Arguments for Balance

Proponents argue that balanced budget amendments foster fiscal responsibility, reduce national debt, prevent politicians from overspending, and promote long-term economic stability by constraining discretionary fiscal policy.

Criticisms and Concerns

Economists often caution that strict annual balanced budget rules can be detrimental during economic downturns, forcing pro-cyclical spending cuts that exacerbate recessions. Concerns also exist regarding the potential for manipulation of projections, circumvention through off-budget channels, and the inflexibility of such mandates.

Economic Consensus: Many economists favor multi-year balancing or cyclical adjustments over strict annual requirements to allow for automatic stabilizers and counter-cyclical policy.

Enforceability and Political Dynamics

The enforceability of such amendments is debated, with critics suggesting they could be circumvented or lead to politically difficult choices. The push for amendments is also viewed by some as political posturing, aiming to signal fiscal conservatism without concrete policy proposals.

Teacher's Corner

Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio

Edit and Print Materials from this study in the wiki2web studio

Click here to open the "Balanced Budget Amendment" Wiki2Web Studio curriculum kit

Use the free Wiki2web Studio to generate printable flashcards, worksheets, exams, and export your materials as a web page or an interactive game.

True or False?

Test Your Knowledge!

Gamer's Corner

Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?

Learn about balanced_budget_amendment while playing the wiki2web Clarity Challenge game.

Unlock the mystery image and prove your knowledge by earning trophies. This simple game is addictively fun and is a great way to learn!

Play now

Explore More Topics

Discover other topics to study!

romantic times

peter brown historian

prospect dolerite intrusion

saxons

mount arafat

References

Federal Department of Finance, "Debt Brake," Swiss Confederation, https://www.efd.admin.ch/en/the-debt-brake, retrieved July 26, 2025

House Joint Resolution 579, 74th Congress, 2d session; reproduced in Report 105-3, 105th Congress, 1st session, February 3, 1997, pp. 3â7.

Bureau of Economic Analysis: Gross Domestic Product; December 2010 revision

A full list of references for this article are available at the Balanced budget amendment Wikipedia page

Feedback & Support

To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.

Disclaimer

Important Notice

This content has been generated by an AI model and is intended for informational and educational purposes only. It is based on publicly available data and may not reflect the most current information or all nuances of the topic.

This is not financial or legal advice. The information provided herein should not be considered a substitute for professional consultation with qualified financial advisors, economists, or legal experts. Always consult with appropriate professionals for advice tailored to specific circumstances.

The creators of this page are not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for any actions taken based on the information provided.

The Fiscal Mandate

💡 Dive in with Flashcard Learning! 💡

Understanding the Balanced Budget Amendment ℹ️

⚖️ Core Principle

📜 Constitutional Framework

🏛️ Global Adoption

International Perspectives 🌍

🇩🇪 Germany: The "Schuldenbremse"

🇪🇸 Spain: Constitutional Reform

🇨🇭 Switzerland: Cyclical Adjustment

🇭🇰 Hong Kong: Basic Law Mandate

The United States Context 🇺🇸

🏛️ State-Level Provisions

📜 Federal Proposals and History

📊 Debt Trends

Historical Trajectory ⏳

📜 Early Concepts

📈 Mid-to-Late 20th Century

💡 The Clinton Era and Beyond

Economic and Political Debate 🗣️

✅ Arguments for Balance

⚠️ Criticisms and Concerns

⚖️ Enforceability and Political Dynamics

Teacher's Corner 🧑‍🏫

Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio

True or False? 🤔

❓ Test Your Knowledge! ❓

Gamer's Corner 🎮

Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?

Explore More Topics

📜 Discover other topics to study!

References

📜 References

Feedback & Support 👍

To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.

Disclaimer ⚠️

📜 Important Notice

Dive in with Flashcard Learning!

Understanding the Balanced Budget Amendment

Core Principle

Constitutional Framework

Global Adoption

International Perspectives

Germany: The "Schuldenbremse"

Spain: Constitutional Reform

Switzerland: Cyclical Adjustment

Hong Kong: Basic Law Mandate

The United States Context

State-Level Provisions

Federal Proposals and History

Debt Trends

Historical Trajectory

Early Concepts

Mid-to-Late 20th Century

The Clinton Era and Beyond

Economic and Political Debate

Arguments for Balance

Criticisms and Concerns

Enforceability and Political Dynamics

Teacher's Corner

True or False?

Test Your Knowledge!

Gamer's Corner

Discover other topics to study!

References

Feedback & Support

Disclaimer

Important Notice