This is a visual explainer based on the Wikipedia article on David Hume's 'The History of England'. Read the full source article here. (opens in new tab)

Hume's Chronicle

A scholarly exploration of David Hume's monumental history, detailing its publication, composition, narrative scope, philosophical underpinnings, and critical reception.

Begin Exploration ๐Ÿ‘‡ Explore Ideas ๐Ÿ’ก

Dive in with Flashcard Learning!


When you are ready...
๐ŸŽฎ Play the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge Game๐ŸŽฎ

Overview

The Monumental Work

David Hume's The History of England is a multi-volume historical narrative that spans from the Roman invasion of Britain to the Glorious Revolution of 1688. Written and published in installments between 1754 and 1762, it was Hume's most ambitious literary undertaking.

Author and Context

Authored by the renowned Scottish philosopher David Hume, the work was composed during his tenure as librarian for the Faculty of Advocates in Edinburgh. It reflects his deep engagement with political philosophy, constitutional theory, and the intellectual currents of the Enlightenment.

Reception and Impact

Upon its initial release, Hume's History was met with significant controversy and outrage from various political factions. Despite this, it achieved remarkable commercial success, becoming a best-seller and establishing itself as the standard history of England for its era, providing Hume with long-sought financial independence.

Scope and Structure

The complete work covers the period from Julius Caesar's invasion (55 BC) to the Revolution of 1688. It is arranged chronologically, though published in volumes that did not strictly follow this order. The narrative encompasses England, Wales, Scotland, and Ireland.

Publication History

A Phased Release

Hume initially intended to focus on the reigns of the Stuart monarchs. The publication unfolded over several years, with the final volumes appearing last:

  • 1754: Volume V, covering the reigns of James I and Charles I (published first).
  • 1757: Volume VI, covering the Commonwealth and the reigns of Charles II and James II.
  • 1759: Volumes III and IV, detailing the House of Tudor.
  • 1762: Volumes I and II, covering the period from Julius Caesar to Henry VII (published last).

Due to the titles of the later volumes, the entire work is sometimes referred to as History of Great Britain.

Circumstances of Composition

Legitimizing the Revolution

Hume's primary concern, particularly in his early writings on the Stuarts, was to contextualize and legitimize the Revolution of 1688. He sought to demonstrate that the revolution principles were not inherently radical but rather a necessary response to monarchical overreach, aiming to appeal across political divides.

Navigating Anti-Scottish Sentiment

Writing in an era of significant anti-Scottish prejudice in England, Hume, a Scot himself, employed a sophisticated style to navigate these sensitivities. His work can be seen as a masterclass in addressing national identity and historical interpretation within a complex political landscape.

The Revolution of 1688

Liberty and Precedent

Hume viewed the 1688 Revolution as a pivotal moment that decisively settled key questions in favor of liberty and established the precedent of deposing a monarch, thereby solidifying popular principles within the English Constitution. He argued against the notion of an entirely seamless constitutional evolution, emphasizing the revolutionary break.

Declarations of Right

Hume highlighted the differences between the English Bill of Rights and the Scottish Claim of Right. While the Bill of Rights, influenced by John Locke, focused on parliamentary consent for laws, the Claim of Right, potentially shaped by Viscount Stair, asserted that abuses of power led to forfeiture of the crown. Hume's analysis suggests a nuanced understanding of the constitutional settlement, acknowledging influences beyond pure evolutionary theory.

The House of Tudor

Henry VII to Elizabeth I

This section of Hume's history covers the establishment of the Tudor dynasty by Henry VII, the tumultuous reign of Henry VIII and the English Reformation, the brief Protestant reign of Edward VI, the counter-reformation under Mary I, and concludes with the long reign of Queen Elizabeth I. Hume's portrayal of Elizabeth was controversial, and his examination of the papers concerning Mary, Queen of Scots, led to significant debate.

History of Great Britain

The Stuart Era

Hume's narrative details the reigns of James I and Charles I, exploring attempts at union between Scotland and England, the growing tensions leading to the English Civil War, the Scottish National Covenant, and the Irish rebellion. The work continues through the Commonwealth period, the Restoration under Charles II, and the reign of James II, culminating in the Revolution of 1688.

  • James I's attempts at union and his relatively peaceful reign.
  • Charles I's conflict with Parliament, leading to the Petition of Right and rule without Parliament.
  • The National Covenant in Scotland and the Irish Rebellion of 1641.
  • The English Civil War, the execution of Charles I, and the republican experiment.
  • Cromwell's rule, the Restoration, and the execution of regicides.
  • The reigns of Charles II and James II, culminating in the Glorious Revolution.

The Early History

Anglo-Saxon and Norman Eras

Hume traces the history back to the formation of the Anglo-Saxon kingdoms (the Heptarchy) and the Romano-Welsh period they supplanted. He then covers the era following Magna Carta through the Wars of the Roses, describing it as a time when the English nation was reinvented after Norman subjugation. Hume critiques appeals to an idealized ancient constitution, viewing them as potentially masking ambition.

Constitutional History

Monarchy, Parliament, and Law

Hume's work includes extensive appendices and discursions on constitutional matters. He challenges the notion that absolute monarchy was solely a Stuart innovation, arguing that the Tudors wielded significant power and that the rule of the early Stuarts was milder than Elizabeth's. He traces the convention of parliamentary consent for taxation back to the Lancastrian period and discusses the gradual implementation of Magna Carta.

  • Divine Right: Hume dates the origin of the divine right or patriarchal system to the early Tudors, contrasting it with an earlier "Polish Aristocracy" where kings were elected.
  • Parliamentary Consent: The convention that kings could not raise taxes without parliamentary consent is linked to the Lancastrians' need for support.
  • Magna Carta: Its gradual implementation led to a period resembling Polish aristocracy, before the Tudors established a more centralized authority.
  • Anglo-Saxon Governance: Hume notes the early Saxons' democratic elements but cautions against romanticizing antiquity, highlighting the lack of freedom for Ancient Britons.
  • Rule of Law: Hume suggests that the Tudors and Stuarts, despite absolutist tendencies, laid groundwork for civility and the eventual establishment of a more equitable system of liberty.

Political Economy

Labor, Passions, and Markets

Hume's historical analysis incorporates insights into political economy. He posits that "everything in the world is purchased by labour, and our passions are the only causes of labour," a view closely aligned with Adam Smith. The work includes discussions on the fluctuations in commodity prices, such as corn, across different historical periods.

The Crusades: A Nadir

Folly and Barbarity

Hume viewed the Crusades, beginning in the reign of William Rufus, as a "most signal and most durable monument of human folly." He detailed the violence, such as the massacre of Muslims and Jews after the storming of Jerusalem, while also noting the complex interplay of religious fervor, courage, and barbarity. He contrasted figures like Saladin, whom he admired for his generosity, with Richard Coeur de Lion, whom he characterized as more barbaric.

  • Hume saw the 11th century as the lowest point of Western civilization due to ignorance and disorder.
  • He described the First Crusade's violence and the participants' subsequent contradictory displays of piety.
  • He contrasted the chivalry of Saladin with the "barbarian character" of Richard I, citing Richard's massacre of prisoners.
  • Hume noted Saladin's magnanimity, including his distribution of wealth to charity regardless of religion.
  • This perspective influenced later historians like Edward Gibbon.

Justinian's Pandects

Influence on Law

Hume identified the accidental rediscovery of Justinian's Pandects around 1130 in Amalfi, Italy, as a significant event for European civilization. He recognized its importance for the development of law, noting its influence on Roman Dutch law and Scottish jurisprudence (via Stair's Institutions). While Roman jurisprudence didn't become England's municipal law due to associations with canon law, its principles were gradually absorbed into English common law, refining it from its "rudeness and imperfection."

Philosophy and Intellectual Currents

Critiques and Appraisals

Hume, a key figure of the Scottish Enlightenment, critically assessed contemporary and earlier thinkers. He lauded Isaac Newton as the greatest genius for instruction, while also acknowledging the limits of the mechanical philosophy. He critiqued John Locke and Thomas Hobbes for their political theories, finding Locke's ideas on government susceptible to antinomianism and Hobbes's politics conducive to tyranny. He praised James Harrington's The Commonwealth of Oceana and noted the intellectual contributions of figures like Francis Bacon and John Napier.

  • Newton: Hailed as the greatest genius, though Hume noted limitations in the mechanical philosophy.
  • Locke & Hobbes: Criticized for theories that could support tyranny or licentiousness; Hume rejected the idea of a primeval social contract as a basis for government.
  • Harrington: Praised for his vision in The Commonwealth of Oceana.
  • Bacon & Napier: Recognized for their contributions, though Hume noted Bacon's disdain for Copernicus and criticized Napier, Newton, and James I for producing eschatological literature.
  • Literary Figures: Appreciated Spenser, Shakespeare, Jonson, Milton, and others, while critiquing the "immeasurable licentiousness" of the Restoration period's impact on arts.

Criticism and Revision

Tory Bias and Jefferson's Condemnation

Hume's History faced accusations of historical revisionism, particularly of promoting Tory viewpoints. Thomas Jefferson famously condemned the work as "poison," believing it undermined English constitutional liberties and was more damaging than a large standing army. Jefferson cited John Baxter's "corrected" version as a remedy.

Hume's Own Revisions

Towards the end of his life, Hume acknowledged making over a hundred alterations to the reigns of the first two Stuarts, consistently shifting towards the Tory perspective. He argued that the English constitution before this period should not be viewed as a regular plan of liberty, challenging the Whig historical narrative of continuous freedom.

Further Reading

Scholarly Resources

Explore deeper analyses of Hume's historical work:

  • Sabl, A. Humeโ€™s Politics: Coordination and Crisis in the History of England (Princeton University Press, 2012).
  • Wei, Jua. Commerce and Politics in Humeโ€™s History of England (Boydell and Brewer, 2017).
  • Wootton, D. "David Hume, 'The Historian.'" in The Cambridge Companion to Hume (1993).

Teacher's Corner

Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio

Edit and Print Materials from this study in the wiki2web studio
Click here to open the "The History Of England Hume" Wiki2Web Studio curriculum kit

Use the free Wiki2web Studio to generate printable flashcards, worksheets, exams, and export your materials as a web page or an interactive game.

True or False?

Test Your Knowledge!

Gamer's Corner

Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?

Learn about the_history_of_england_hume while playing the wiki2web Clarity Challenge game.
Unlock the mystery image and prove your knowledge by earning trophies. This simple game is addictively fun and is a great way to learn!

Play now

Explore More Topics

Discover other topics to study!

                                        

References

References

  1.  Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, entry on Hume
  2.  this phenomenon appears to have been defined by David Masson
  3.  See Macaulay's rather dusty account. This Stair is not to be confused with his son, the genocidaire of Glencoe.
  4.  See Scottish National Consciousness in the Age of James VI Arthur H. Williamson
  5.  Humes Letters, OUP, Letters 2 vols. ed.J.Y.T.Greig; More Letters ed. Raymond Klibansky, Ernest Mossner
A full list of references for this article are available at the The History of England (Hume) Wikipedia page

Feedback & Support

To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.

Disclaimer

Important Notice

This page was generated by an Artificial Intelligence and is intended for informational and educational purposes only. The content is based on a snapshot of publicly available data from Wikipedia and may not be entirely accurate, complete, or up-to-date.

This is not academic or historical advice. The information provided on this website is not a substitute for professional historical research, academic consultation, or primary source analysis. Always refer to original texts and consult with qualified historians or scholars for in-depth study.

The creators of this page are not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for any actions taken based on the information provided herein.