What is the legal status of an advance healthcare directive in the U.S. compared to other countries?

In the United States, an advance healthcare directive has legal status as a document. In contrast, in some other countries, it is legally persuasive but may not be considered a formal legal document.

How does a living will relate to an advance directive?

A living will is one specific form of an advance directive, providing instructions for medical treatment.

What is another form of advance directive besides a living will?

Another form of advance directive is a specific type of power of attorney or health care proxy, which authorizes an agent to make decisions on behalf of the individual when they are incapacitated.

Why are individuals encouraged to complete both a living will and a healthcare proxy?

People are often encouraged to complete both a living will and a healthcare proxy to provide comprehensive guidance regarding their care, although these documents can sometimes be combined into a single form.

What is an example of a combined advance directive document in the United States?

An example of combination documents in the United States includes the Five Wishes, which integrates various aspects of advance care planning.

In which country is the term living will commonly recognized vernacular?

The term living will is the commonly recognized vernacular in many countries, especially the United Kingdom.

Does the legality of advance consent for advance healthcare directives vary?

Yes, the legality of advance consent for advance healthcare directives depends on the specific jurisdiction.

What critical deficits in medical care for the dying have studies documented, leading to the need for advance directives?

Numerous studies have documented critical deficits in the medical care of the dying, finding it to be unnecessarily prolonged, painful, expensive, and emotionally burdensome to both patients and their families.

What type of form is depicted in the source material?

The source material depicts a refusal of treatment form, which is a document used to decline specific medical interventions.

Which form of advance directive is considered the oldest?

The living will is considered the oldest form of advance directive.

Who first proposed the concept of a living will, and when and where was it introduced?

The living will was first proposed by an Illinois attorney, Luis Kutner, in a speech to the Euthanasia Society of America in 1967 and was subsequently published in a law journal in 1969.

What legal precedent did Luis Kutner draw upon when devising the living will, and how did this influence its name?

Luis Kutner drew from existing estate law, which allows individuals to control property affairs after death, to devise a way for individuals to express their healthcare desires when incapacitated. This document was dubbed the living will because it was intended for use while an individual was still alive but unable to make decisions.

What was the purpose of the U.S. Patient Self-Determination Act (PSDA) when it went into effect?

The U.S. Patient Self-Determination Act (PSDA), which went into effect in December 1991, required healthcare providers, such as hospitals, nursing homes, and home health agencies, to give patients information about their rights to make advance directives under state law.

What kind of instructions does a living will typically provide?

A living will usually provides specific directives about the course of treatment healthcare providers and caregivers are to follow.

Can a living will be used to refuse specific medical treatments?

Yes, in some cases, a living will may forbid the use of various kinds of burdensome medical treatment.

What other wishes can a living will express regarding medical support?

A living will may also be used to express wishes about the use or foregoing of food and water, if supplied via tubes or other medical devices.

Under what specific condition is a living will activated?

The living will is used only if the individual has become unable to give informed consent or refusal due to incapacity.

What is the range of specificity for a living will?

A living will can be very specific or very general in its instructions.

Can you provide an example of a common statement found in a living will?

An example of a statement sometimes found in a living will is: If I suffer an incurable, irreversible illness, disease, or condition and my attending physician determines that my condition is terminal, I direct that life-sustaining measures that would serve only to prolong my dying be withheld or discontinued.

What specific medical services might be addressed in a detailed living will?

More specific living wills may include information regarding an individual's desire for services such as analgesia (pain relief), antibiotics, hydration, feeding, and the use of ventilators or cardiopulmonary resuscitation.

What factor increases the likelihood of adults completing advance directive documents?

Studies have shown that adults are more likely to complete these documents if they are written in everyday language and are less focused on technical treatments.

What issue did public advocacy groups identify regarding advance directives in the late 1980s?

By the late 1980s, public advocacy groups became aware that many people remained unaware of advance directives, and even fewer actually completed them.

What was identified as a contributing factor to the low awareness and completion rates of advance directives?

In part, the low awareness and completion rates of advance directives were seen as a failure of healthcare providers and medical organizations to promote and support the use of these documents.

How did the public respond to the low awareness of advance directives, and what legislative act resulted from this?

The public's response was to press for further legislative support, which resulted in the Patient Self-Determination Act of 1990. This act attempted to address the awareness problem by requiring healthcare institutions to better promote and support the use of advance directives.

What was the adoption rate of living wills among Americans by 2007?

Living wills proved to be very popular, and by 2007, 41% of Americans had completed a living will.

How did state legislatures in the U.S. respond to the public's need for living wills?

In response to public needs, state legislatures soon passed laws in support of living wills in virtually every state in the union.

What limitations were discovered regarding living wills despite their popularity?

As living wills became better recognized, key deficits were discovered; most tended to be limited in scope and often failed to fully address presenting problems and needs.

What potential issue arose from how some individuals drafted their living wills?

Many individuals wrote out their wishes in ways that might conflict with quality medical practice.

What conclusion was reached about the sufficiency of living wills, and what development did this lead to?

Ultimately, it was determined that a living will alone might be insufficient to address many important healthcare decisions, which led to the development of what some have called second generation advance directives, such as the health care proxy appointment or medical power of attorney.

Why is it important to regularly update living wills?

Living wills reflect a moment in time and may therefore need regular updating to ensure that the correct course of action can be chosen in evolving medical situations.

What is the historical origin of power of attorney statutes in the United States?

Power of attorney statutes have existed in the United States since the days of common law, which refers to laws brought from England during the colonial period.

What was the fundamental purpose of early power of attorney documents?

These early powers of attorney allowed an individual to name someone to act in their stead.

How were durable powers of attorney for health care and healthcare proxy appointment documents developed?

Drawing upon existing power of attorney laws, durable powers of attorney for health care and healthcare proxy appointment documents were created and codified in law, allowing an individual to appoint someone to make healthcare decisions on their behalf if they become incapable of making their wishes known.

Is it beneficial for individuals to have both a durable power of attorney and a healthcare proxy?

People will normally benefit from having both a durable power of attorney and a healthcare proxy to ensure comprehensive coverage for their decision-making needs.

What is the primary function of a healthcare proxy document?

A healthcare proxy document appoints a person, the proxy, who can make decisions on behalf of the granting individual in the event of incapacity.

How do the decisions made by a healthcare proxy differ from those in a living will?

The appointed representative in a healthcare proxy is authorized to make real-time decisions in actual circumstances, as opposed to advance decisions framed in hypothetical situations, as might be recorded in a living will.

How quickly was the healthcare proxy adopted in the U.S.?

The healthcare proxy was rapidly accepted within the U.S., and authorizing legislation was soon enacted in most states.

What is a potential problem with a conventional healthcare proxy?

One problem with a conventional healthcare proxy is that it may not be possible for the appointed proxy to determine what care choices the individual would have made if still capable, as healthcare proxies may be too vague for meaningful interpretation.

According to a study, how accurate are next-of-kin surrogates in predicting an incapacitated person's treatment preferences?

A study comparing next-of-kin decisions on behalf of an incapacitated person (who later recovered) found that these surrogates chose correctly 68% of the time overall.

What is a values history in the context of advance directives?

A values history is a two-part advance directive instrument that elicits patient values about terminal medical care and therapy-specific directives, serving as an alternative to a conventional healthcare proxy.

What is the primary goal of a values history advance directive?

The goal of a values history advance directive is to move away from a focus on specific treatments and medical procedures to a focus on patient values and personal goals.

What factors are strong motivators for individuals to refuse a wide range of end-of-life therapies?

Studies suggest that values regarding financial and psychological burden are strong motivators in not wanting a broad array of end-of-life therapies.

What is a medical directive as an alternative to a healthcare proxy?

A medical directive is another alternative to a conventional healthcare proxy, which is a document that describes six case scenarios for advance medical decision-making.

How does a medical directive facilitate advance medical decision-making?

The scenarios in a medical directive are each associated with a roster of commonly considered medical procedures and interventions, allowing the individual to decide in advance which treatments are wanted or not wanted under the circumstances.

Are non-statutory advance directives generally accepted?

A study conducted to address concerns that a non-statutory advance directive might leave an incapacitated person with a document that may not be honored found that they are generally accepted.

What is a psychiatric advance directive (PAD)?

A psychiatric advance directive (PAD), also known as a mental health advance directive, is a written document that describes what a person wants to happen if in the future they are judged to have a mental disorder in such a way that they are deemed unable to decide for themselves or to communicate effectively.

What specific information can a PAD convey?

A PAD can inform others about what treatment a person wants or does not want from psychiatrists or other mental health professionals, and it can identify a person to whom they have given the authority to make decisions on their behalf.

Is a mental health advance directive a type of advance healthcare directive?

Yes, a mental health advance directive is one kind of advance healthcare directive.

Advance Healthcare Directive Wiki: Future Care, Your Terms: An In-Depth Guide to Advance Healthcare Directives

Dive in with Flashcard Learning!

When you are ready...
🎮 Play the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge Game🎮

Defining the Directive

A Legal Framework for Autonomy

An advance healthcare directive is a legal document that specifies what actions should be taken for a person's health if they are no longer able to make decisions for themselves due to illness or incapacity. Also known as a living will, personal directive, or advance decision, it serves as a voice for the patient when they cannot speak. The legal status of these documents can vary by jurisdiction, with some recognizing them as binding legal instruments and others as persuasive guidance.

Two Primary Forms

Advance directives typically manifest in two principal forms, which can be used separately or in combination:

Living Will: This document provides specific instructions about medical treatments and interventions that an individual consents to or refuses.
Healthcare Proxy (or Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care): This document appoints a specific person (an agent or proxy) to make healthcare decisions on the individual's behalf when they are incapacitated.

Combined and Comprehensive Planning

Individuals are often encouraged to complete both a living will and a healthcare proxy to provide comprehensive guidance. The living will outlines the "what," while the proxy designates the "who." Some frameworks, such as the "Five Wishes" document in the United States, integrate these elements into a single, more holistic form that addresses medical, personal, emotional, and spiritual needs.

The Rationale for Directives

A Response to Modern Medicine

Advance directives emerged as a direct response to the increasing sophistication and prevalence of medical technology. While life-sustaining treatments can be miraculous, they also have the potential to prolong the dying process in ways that may not align with a patient's wishes. These documents provide a mechanism for individuals to maintain control over their medical journey, even in the face of severe illness.

Addressing Deficits in End-of-Life Care

Numerous studies have documented significant shortcomings in the medical care of the dying. Research has found end-of-life care to be unnecessarily prolonged, painful, and expensive. This creates a profound emotional and financial burden on both patients and their families. Advance directives aim to mitigate these issues by ensuring that care aligns with the patient's pre-stated values and preferences, promoting a more dignified and less burdensome experience.

The Living Will

Historical Origins

The living will is the oldest form of advance directive, first proposed in 1967 by Illinois attorney Luis Kutner. Drawing from established estate law that allows individuals to control property after death, Kutner devised a way for a person to control their healthcare wishes while still alive but incapacitated. This concept of a "will for the living" quickly gained traction, leading to widespread legislative support.

Legal Recognition in the U.S.

The popularity of living wills culminated in the federal Patient Self-Determination Act (PSDA), which went into effect in December 1991. This landmark legislation required healthcare institutions like hospitals and nursing homes to inform patients of their right to create advance directives under state law. By 2007, an estimated 41% of Americans had completed a living will, demonstrating its significant public acceptance.

Content and Specificity

A living will can be general or highly specific. It often contains directives to withhold or discontinue life-sustaining measures in the event of a terminal, incurable, or irreversible condition. More detailed documents may specify wishes regarding:

Analgesia (pain relief)
Antibiotics
Artificial hydration and feeding
Use of ventilators
Cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR)

However, research indicates that documents written in accessible, everyday language are more likely to be completed.

Identified Limitations

As living wills became more common, their limitations became apparent. They were often too limited in scope to address the complexity of real-world medical situations. Furthermore, an individual's written wishes could sometimes conflict with best medical practices or fail to anticipate specific clinical scenarios. These challenges highlighted the need for a more flexible, real-time decision-making tool, leading to the development of the healthcare proxy.

The Healthcare Proxy

Appointing a Decision-Maker

A healthcare proxy, also known as a durable power of attorney for health care, is a legal document that appoints a specific person (the proxy or agent) to make medical decisions on behalf of an individual if they become incapacitated. This appointed representative is granted the same rights to request or refuse treatment that the individual would have. The key advantage is the ability to make real-time decisions in actual circumstances, rather than relying on hypothetical scenarios outlined in a static document.

The Challenge of Accuracy

A primary challenge with proxies is ensuring the agent's decisions accurately reflect the patient's wishes. Vague instructions can lead to misinterpretation. A systematic review found that even next-of-kin surrogates, who are presumed to know the patient well, incorrectly predicted a patient's end-of-life preferences in approximately one-third of cases (making correct choices 68% of the time overall). This highlights the importance of clear and thorough communication between the individual and their chosen proxy.

Values-Based Alternatives

To improve the proxy's effectiveness, alternative approaches have been developed:

The Values History: This instrument shifts the focus from specific treatments to the patient's core values and personal goals. It helps the proxy understand the "why" behind a person's wishes, such as concerns about financial or psychological burdens on their family.
The Medical Directive: This document presents several detailed clinical scenarios (e.g., coma with low chance of recovery) and allows the individual to select or reject a list of common interventions for each situation, providing more concrete guidance.

Psychiatric Advance Directives (PADs)

Planning for Mental Health Crises

A Psychiatric Advance Directive (PAD) is a specialized legal document created by a person to express their preferences for future mental health treatment. It is designed to be used during a crisis when they may be deemed unable to make decisions for themselves. A PAD can specify desired (or undesired) treatments and clinicians, and can also appoint a proxy specifically for mental health decisions.

Clinical and Legal Status

In the United States, 25 states have passed legislation establishing legal authority for PADs. Furthermore, The Joint Commission (JCAHO) requires accredited behavioral health facilities to ask patients if they have a PAD. A Duke University study funded by the NIH demonstrated that facilitated PADs can increase therapeutic alliance, enhance patient satisfaction and autonomy, and improve decision-making capacity among individuals with severe mental illness.

Barriers to Implementation

Despite their benefits, PADs are underutilized. National surveys in the U.S. show that while about 70% of individuals in the public mental health system would want a PAD, fewer than 10% have completed one. Key barriers include a lack of public awareness and a reported lack of knowledge and resources among clinicians to help patients create these important documents. However, surveys show that clinicians with more legal knowledge about PADs have more favorable attitudes towards their use.

Global Perspectives

United States

The U.S. has a significant need for advance care planning, with nearly two million Americans in nursing homes and over 1.4 million surviving via feeding tubes. Studies show 70-95% of people would prefer to refuse aggressive treatment in poor prognosis states. All states recognize some form of advance directive. The Patient Self-Determination Act of 1990 was a federal milestone. Some states, like Pennsylvania with its Act 169 of 2006, provide comprehensive statutory frameworks for combined living wills and healthcare powers of attorney.

United Kingdom

In England and Wales, the Mental Capacity Act 2005 provides the legal framework for advance directives. An individual can make a legally binding advance decision to refuse specific treatment for a time when they lack mental capacity. For refusals of life-prolonging treatment, the directive must be written, signed, and witnessed. Additionally, clinical plans like the ReSPECT (Recommended Summary Plan for Emergency Care and Treatment) process are used to record patient preferences after discussion with healthcare professionals.

Canada

Canada focuses on a process called Advance Care Planning (ACP), which encourages individuals to appoint a "substitute decision-maker." While polling shows 96% of Canadians believe end-of-life planning is important, only about 13% have created a plan. The conversation is closely linked to the national debate on medical assistance in dying (MAiD), with many advocating for improved palliative and hospice care as a foundational step.

European Union

Laws vary across the EU. Germany passed a law in 2009 establishing legally binding advance directives based on the right of self-determination. Italy legalized directives in 2018, following high-profile right-to-die cases like those of Piergiorgio Welby and Eluana Englaro, which spurred years of national debate. Switzerland passed a law in 2013 allowing any adult with capacity to create a legally binding directive and appoint a proxy.

Asia & Oceania

In Australia, laws vary by state; Queensland, for example, has specific legislation, while Tasmania does not. In Japan, directives are not legally recognized, though private organizations provide non-binding "living will" forms. In contrast, South Korea legally recognized advance directives in 2016 with the Act on Decisions on Life-Sustaining Treatment. In India, the Supreme Court legalized living wills in 2018, affirming that the right to a dignified life extends to the right to a dignified death.

Other Nations

In Israel, a 2005 law allows for advance directives, but the right to refuse care is limited to terminally ill patients with a life expectancy under six months. In many parts of Africa, such as Nigeria, advance directives have not yet been legalized, and end-of-life decisions continue to be guided primarily by tradition and family consensus rather than individual written directives.

Teacher's Corner

Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio

Edit and Print Materials from this study in the wiki2web studio

Click here to open the "Advance Healthcare Directive" Wiki2Web Studio curriculum kit

Use the free Wiki2web Studio to generate printable flashcards, worksheets, exams, and export your materials as a web page or an interactive game.

True or False?

Test Your Knowledge!

Gamer's Corner

Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?

Learn about advance_healthcare_directive while playing the wiki2web Clarity Challenge game.

Unlock the mystery image and prove your knowledge by earning trophies. This simple game is addictively fun and is a great way to learn!

Play now

Explore More Topics

Discover other topics to study!

agreed framework

marathon county wisconsin

2002 denver broncos season

united nations security council resolution 1718

prytaneis

kuril islands

order of prince yaroslav the wise

sanchia of provence

addison-wesley

dominic maguire bishop

References

Docker, C. Advance Directives/Living Wills in: McLean S.A.M., "Contemporary Issues in Law, Medicine and Ethics," Dartmouth 1996

Choice in Dying (now: Partnership in Caring). Choice in Dying: an historical perspective. CID 1035-30th Street, N.W. Washington, DC. 2007

Patient Self-Determination Act U.S.C.A. 1395cc & 1396a, 4206-4207, 4751, Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990, P.L:.b 101-508 (101ST Cong. 2nd Sess. Nov. 5, 1990) (West Supp., 1991).

Docker, C. Advance Directives/Living Wills in: McLean S.A.M., Contemporary Issues in Law, Medicine and Ethics," Dartmouth 1996:182.

Anthony, J. Your aging parents: document their wishes. American Health. May 1995. pp. 58-61, 109.

American Bar Association. Patient Self-Determination Act: State Law Guide. American Bar Association Commission on Legal Problems of The Elder. August 1991.

Charmaine Jones, With living wills gaining in popularity, push grows for more extensive directive, Crain's Cleveland Business, August 20, 2007.

American Bar Association. Patient Self-Determination Act: State Law Guide. American Bar Association Commission on Legal Problems of the Elderly. August 1991.

Lambert P, Gibson, JM, Nathanson, P. The Values History: An Innovation in Surrogate Medical Decision-Making, Med. & Health Care, 202-212 (1990)

"Advance Directives for Mental Health Treatment" Debra S. Srebnik and John Q. La Fond Psychiatric Services, Volume 50, Number 7: 919 - 925, July 1999

"Law and Psychiatry: Psychiatric Advance Directives and the Treatment of Committed Patients" Paul S. Appelbaum, Psychiatric Services, Volume 55, Number 7: 751 - 763, July 2004

"Clinical Decision Making and Views About Psychiatric Advance Directives" Eric B. Elbogen, Marvin S. Swartz, Richard Van Dorn, Jeffrey W. Swanson, Mimi Kim, and Anna Scheyett Psychiatric Services, Volume 57, Number 3: 350-355, March 2006

US Congress, Office of Technology Assessment. Life-Sustaining Technologies and the Elderly. OTA-BA-306. Washington, DC: US Gov't Printing Office. July, 1987.

Covinsky, KE; Goldman, L; Cook, EF; etal. The impact of serious illness on patient's families. Journal of the American Medical Association. 1994;272(23):1839-1844.

Heap, MJ; etal. Elderly patients' preferences concerning life support treatment. Anaesthesia. 1993;48:1027-1033.

Patrick, DL; etal. Measuring preferences for health states worse than death. Medical Decision-Making. 1994;14:9-19.

Conolly, Ceci. "Obama takes personal approach in AARP speech," The Washington Post, July 29, 2009.

A full list of references for this article are available at the Advance healthcare directive Wikipedia page

Feedback & Support

To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.

Disclaimer

Important Notice

This page was generated by an Artificial Intelligence and is intended for informational and educational purposes only. The content is based on a snapshot of publicly available data from Wikipedia and may not be entirely accurate, complete, or up-to-date.

This is not legal or medical advice. The information provided on this website is not a substitute for professional legal or medical consultation. Creating an advance healthcare directive is a significant legal and personal decision. Always seek the advice of a qualified attorney and a healthcare provider to understand the laws in your jurisdiction and to ensure your wishes are clearly and legally documented.

The creators of this page are not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for any actions taken based on the information provided herein.

Advance Healthcare Directives

💡 Dive in with Flashcard Learning! 💡

Defining the Directive ℹ️

⚖️ A Legal Framework for Autonomy

✍️ Two Primary Forms

🧩 Combined and Comprehensive Planning

The Rationale for Directives 🏛️

🩺 A Response to Modern Medicine

💔 Addressing Deficits in End-of-Life Care

The Living Will ✍️

📜 Historical Origins

🏛️ Legal Recognition in the U.S.

📋 Content and Specificity

⚠️ Identified Limitations

The Healthcare Proxy 🤝

🗣️ Appointing a Decision-Maker

🎯 The Challenge of Accuracy

💡 Values-Based Alternatives

Psychiatric Advance Directives (PADs) 🧠

🛡️ Planning for Mental Health Crises

📈 Clinical and Legal Status

🚧 Barriers to Implementation

Global Perspectives 🌍

🇺🇸 United States

🇬🇧 United Kingdom

🇨🇦 Canada

🇪🇺 European Union

🌏 Asia & Oceania

🌍 Other Nations

Teacher's Corner 🧑‍🏫

Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio

True or False? 🤔

❓ Test Your Knowledge! ❓

Gamer's Corner 🎮

Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?

Explore More Topics

📜 Discover other topics to study!

References

📜 References

Feedback & Support 👍

To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.

Disclaimer ⚠️

📜 Important Notice

Dive in with Flashcard Learning!

Defining the Directive

A Legal Framework for Autonomy

Two Primary Forms

Combined and Comprehensive Planning

The Rationale for Directives

A Response to Modern Medicine

Addressing Deficits in End-of-Life Care

The Living Will

Historical Origins

Legal Recognition in the U.S.

Content and Specificity

Identified Limitations

The Healthcare Proxy

Appointing a Decision-Maker

The Challenge of Accuracy

Values-Based Alternatives

Psychiatric Advance Directives (PADs)

Planning for Mental Health Crises

Clinical and Legal Status

Barriers to Implementation

Global Perspectives

United States

United Kingdom

Canada

European Union

Asia & Oceania

Other Nations

Teacher's Corner

True or False?

Test Your Knowledge!

Gamer's Corner

Discover other topics to study!

References

Feedback & Support

Disclaimer

Important Notice