What is the current status of official bilateral relations between the People's Republic of China (PRC) and the Holy See?

There are no official bilateral relations between the People's Republic of China (PRC) and the Holy See. The Holy See continues to recognize the Republic of China (Taiwan) as the representative of China, a stance it has maintained since establishing relations with the ROC government in 1942.

What are the primary reasons for the strained relations between the Holy See and the PRC?

Relations have been strained due to the Chinese Communist Party's (CCP) policies that restrict religious activities and its involvement in the appointment of Catholic bishops in mainland China. These issues have been central points of contention between the two entities.

What significant agreement was reached between the PRC and the Holy See in September 2018?

In September 2018, the PRC and the Holy See signed a provisional agreement concerning the appointment of bishops. This agreement allows the Pope to appoint and veto bishops who are approved by the CCP, marking a significant step in their relationship, though not establishing formal diplomatic ties.

How has the 2018 agreement on bishop appointments been renewed?

The provisional agreement signed in 2018 has been renewed multiple times. It was extended for another two years in October 2020, again in October 2022, and most recently for four years in October 2024, indicating an ongoing, albeit complex, engagement on this issue.

What accusation did the Vatican make against the Chinese government regarding the 2018 agreement in November 2022?

In November 2022, the Vatican accused the Chinese government of violating the terms of the 2018 agreement. This accusation stemmed from the installation of Giovanni Peng Weizhao as an auxiliary bishop in Jiangxi, a district not recognized as a diocese by the Vatican.

What were the two conditions set by the Beijing government for re-establishing relations with the Holy See?

The Beijing government stipulated two conditions for re-establishing relations: first, that the Holy See must not interfere in religious matters within China, and second, that the Holy See must break its ties with the Taipei government, aligning with Beijing's One China principle.

What is the Holy See's stance on moving its nunciature to Beijing?

The Holy See has indicated that it would only move its nunciature (diplomatic mission) to Beijing if it receives guarantees of religious freedom in mainland China. This condition highlights the Vatican's priority in ensuring the rights and freedoms of Catholics in China.

What is the central issue regarding Catholic bishops in mainland China from the Vatican's perspective?

From the Vatican's perspective, the most crucial issue in the bilateral relationship is the procedure for appointing Catholic bishops in mainland China. The Holy See maintains that this is the exclusive prerogative of the Pope.

How does the Chinese government approach the appointment of bishops?

Since the 1950s, the Chinese government has maintained that bishops in China should be elected by Chinese Catholics through the Chinese Catholic Patriotic Association (CCPA). This association is part of the United Front system, giving the Communist Party ultimate control over bishop appointments.

What is the Vatican's view on bishops appointed through the Chinese Catholic Patriotic Association?

The Vatican considers bishops ordained through processes not approved by the Pope to be valid but illicit. This means the Vatican acknowledges their status as bishops but views the appointment process as sinful, potentially leading to automatic excommunication under canon law, though the Vatican has not publicly announced such excommunications.

What was Pope Pius XII's directive to Chinese Catholics during the Chinese Civil War?

During the Chinese Civil War, Pope Pius XII forbade Chinese Catholics from joining the Communist Party or participating in its activities. This directive reflected the Vatican's stance against the Communist regime at the time.

What happened in 1951 that led to the PRC breaking diplomatic relations with the Holy See?

In 1951, following a manufactured controversy involving a mortar found at the Holy See's legation, the PRC arrested and executed a businessman named Antonio Riva and deported the papal nuncio. The Holy See's diplomatic mission was banished for alleged 'espionage,' leading to the PRC breaking off diplomatic relations.

How did the Catholic Church in China develop after the PRC broke relations with the Holy See?

After the break in relations, the Catholic Church in China bifurcated into two communities: the "Patriotic" Church, which operates with the approval of Chinese authorities, and the "Underground" Church, which professes loyalty to the Pope. The term "Underground" refers to the lack of official approval rather than secrecy.

What was the Vatican's policy shift known as 'Ostpolitik' and how did it relate to communist countries?

Following the Cuban Missile Crisis, the Vatican adopted 'Ostpolitik,' a foreign relations approach that downplayed ideological conflicts and reduced anti-communist rhetoric. This policy aimed to make sacraments and church public life more accessible in communist countries.

What significant change did Pope John Paul II permit in 1978 regarding the Underground Church?

In 1978, Pope John Paul II permitted the Underground Church to ordain new bishops without prior Vatican approval, a departure from the norm. This decision aimed to support the continuity of the Church's hierarchy in China.

How did Pope John Paul II attempt to signal a desire for improved relations with the PRC in 1981?

In 1981, during his first trip to Asia, Pope John Paul II delivered a speech in the Philippines stating that the Christian message is universal and that it is possible to be both authentically Christian and authentically Chinese. This was interpreted as a gesture towards improving relations with the PRC.

Why did Pope John Paul II's 1982 letter to Chinese bishops offend the PRC government?

The PRC government took offense at Pope John Paul II's 1982 letter to Chinese bishops, which compared the experience of Chinese Catholics to early Christians and implicitly criticized the state of religious freedom in China. The government perceived this as unwelcome criticism and interference.

What action did the Vatican take in 1984 that might have paved the way for new bishop appointments in China?

In 1984, the Vatican yearbook removed the titles of foreign missionaries who had served as archbishops and bishops in China but had not been physically present in their dioceses for decades. This action signaled that the Vatican was no longer operating under the assumption that these missionaries represented the dioceses, potentially clearing the path for new appointments.

What was the PRC's reaction to Pope John Paul II's canonization of 120 Chinese martyrs in 2000?

The PRC government reacted negatively to Pope John Paul II's canonization of 120 Chinese Catholics as martyrs in 2000, viewing them as collaborators with foreign imperialism. The timing of the announcement on China's National Day was also seen as offensive, leading to a protest from the PRC.

How did Pope John Paul II express regret regarding the Catholic Church's past behavior in China?

In a message commemorating Matteo Ricci's arrival in Beijing around 2001, Pope John Paul II expressed regret for any behavior by Christians that might have given an impression of disrespect or lack of esteem for the Chinese people. He asked for forgiveness and understanding for those who may have felt hurt by such actions.

What was the significance of ROC President Chen Shui-bian attending Pope John Paul II's funeral in 2005?

ROC President Chen Shui-bian's attendance at Pope John Paul II's funeral in 2005 was seen as a diplomatic move by Taiwan. The PRC protested this attendance, viewing it as an opportunity for secessionist activity, while the Vatican stated that no specific invitations were sent and all were welcome.

What was the main message of Pope Benedict XVI's 2007 open letter to Chinese Catholics?

In his 2007 letter, Pope Benedict XVI affirmed that there is only one Catholic Church in China, uniting both the Patriotic and Underground communities. He also reiterated that sacraments performed by priests not in unity with the Vatican are valid but illicit, and stated that the Chinese Catholic Patriotic Association's involvement in bishop appointments violates Catholic doctrine.

What change did Pope Benedict XVI's 2007 letter introduce regarding bishop ordinations?

Pope Benedict XVI's 2007 letter revoked the permission previously granted by the Vatican in 1978 to the Underground Church to appoint bishops without Vatican approval. This move aimed to centralize the appointment process under papal authority.

How did Pope Francis express his desire for improved relations with China?

Pope Francis stated in a 2015 media interview his wish to visit China and improve the relationship between the Holy See and the PRC. This desire reflects a continued effort to foster dialogue and understanding.

What gesture of goodwill occurred when the Pope's plane crossed Chinese airspace in 2014?

In August 2014, as Pope Francis' plane flew over China en route to South Korea, he sent a telegram to the Chinese people expressing his best wishes. This act was seen as a diplomatic overture and a sign of respect.

What criticism did Cardinal Joseph Zen Ze-kiun voice regarding the warming of Vatican-China relations?

Cardinal Joseph Zen Ze-kiun, the former Bishop of Hong Kong, criticized the warming diplomatic relationships between the Vatican and China, describing it as 'selling out' the Catholic Church in China. His concern stemmed from the process involving the resignation of several bishops from the underground church.

What was the stated purpose of the 2018 provisional agreement between the Holy See and China, according to the Vatican spokesman?

According to Vatican spokesman Greg Burke, the 2018 agreement was not political but pastoral. Its aim was to allow the faithful to have bishops who are in communion with Rome while also being recognized by Chinese authorities.

What role did the Chinese government play in the bishop appointment process under the 2018 agreement?

Under the 2018 agreement, the Chinese government recommends bishops before they are appointed by the Pope. The agreement also stipulates that the Pope retains the authority to veto a bishop recommended by China.

How did Pope Francis respond to the 2018 agreement concerning existing bishops?

Following the 2018 agreement, Pope Francis approved seven bishops who had been appointed by Beijing. He also withdrew Church censures against six of these bishops and one deceased bishop who had received episcopal consecration without papal approval. Additionally, he demoted one Underground Church bishop and dismissed another.

What commitment did the Catholic Church in China make following the 2018 agreement?

On September 23, 2018, the Catholic Church in China pledged to remain loyal to the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). This pledge followed the signing of the provisional agreement on bishop appointments.

What was Willy Wo-Lap Lam's analysis of the 2018 Vatican-China agreement in the context of Xi Jinping's policies?

Willy Wo-Lap Lam suggested that the 2018 agreement reflected the Chinese government's long-standing goal to end the Holy See's recognition of Taiwan. He also noted that it coincided with Xi Jinping's campaign, launched in spring 2018, to increase state control over foreign religious institutions.

What actions by local Chinese authorities followed the 2018 agreement, according to reports?

In October 2018, shortly after the agreement was signed, local Chinese government officials reportedly destroyed two Marian shrines, one in Shanxi province and another in Guizhou province. These actions raised concerns about the enforcement of the agreement.

What happened in April 2023 regarding the appointment of a bishop in Shanghai?

In April 2023, Bishop Shen Bin, formerly the Bishop of Haimen, was installed in the Diocese of Shanghai. The Vatican learned of this appointment only a few days prior, leading the Vatican to state that China had unilaterally appointed the bishop, potentially violating the agreement's terms.

What occurred regarding the election of a bishop in the Diocese of Xinxiang during the sede vacante period in 2025?

During the sede vacante period following Pope Francis' death in April 2025, the Diocese of Xinxiang 'elected' Father Li Janlin as bishop. Because a new pope had not yet been elected, the Holy See could not recognize or ratify this appointment at that time.

What diplomatic developments occurred in June and September 2025 under the new Pope Leo XIV?

Under Pope Leo XIV, Joseph Lin Yuntuan was nominated as auxiliary bishop of Fuzhou in June 2025, with approval from Chinese authorities. In September 2025, the reorganization of the Dioceses of Xuanhua and Xiwanzi into a new Diocese of Zhangjiakou was approved, with Joseph Wang Zhengui appointed as its first bishop recognized by both the Vatican and Beijing. Joseph Ma Yan'en was appointed auxiliary bishop of the new diocese.

What was the historical context of the Holy See's recognition of the Republic of China (Taiwan)?

The Holy See established relations with the Republic of China (ROC) government in 1942. It has continued to recognize the ROC as the representative of China even after the establishment of the People's Republic of China (PRC) on the mainland, leading to the absence of official relations between the Holy See and the PRC.

What is the significance of the term 'valid but illicit' in the context of Chinese Catholic bishop ordinations?

The term 'valid but illicit' means that the Vatican acknowledges the sacramental validity of ordinations performed by bishops appointed without papal approval, but considers the process itself to be against canon law and therefore illicit or unlawful. This distinction allows the Church to recognize the individuals as bishops while still upholding the authority of the Pope in appointments.

How did the PRC frame its actions against the Holy See's diplomatic mission in 1951?

The PRC framed its actions, including the deportation of the apostolic nuncio and the banishment of the diplomatic mission, in terms of Chinese Catholics reclaiming their church. These actions were also presented within the broader context of opposition to Western imperialism.

What was the Vatican's stance on the bishop conferences organized by both the Patriotic and Underground Churches in 1989?

In 1989, both the Chinese Catholic Patriotic Association and the Underground Church organized their own bishop's conferences. The Vatican recognized neither of these conferences, maintaining its own position on episcopal governance.

What did Pope Francis's message to Chinese Catholics in September 2018 encourage them to do?

Pope Francis encouraged Chinese Catholics to be good citizens, loving their homeland and serving their country diligently. He also urged them to make a prophetic and constructive contribution to society, which might include offering criticism for the sake of building a more just and humane society.

China U2013holy See Relations Wiki: Diplomatic Currents: The Vatican and the People's Republic of China

Dive in with Flashcard Learning!

When you are ready...
🎮 Play the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge Game🎮

Current Relations

No Official Ties

The People's Republic of China (PRC) and the Holy See currently maintain no official bilateral diplomatic relations. This absence stems from the Holy See's continued recognition of the Republic of China (Taiwan) as the legitimate representative of China, a stance established in 1942.

Strained Dynamics

Relations have historically been strained, primarily due to the PRC's policies restricting religious activities and its assertion of control over the appointment of Catholic bishops within mainland China. These issues represent significant points of contention in any potential normalization of ties.

Provisional Agreement

Despite the lack of formal diplomatic ties, a significant development occurred in September 2018 with the signing of a provisional agreement concerning the appointment of bishops. This agreement, renewed multiple times, allows the Pope to appoint bishops approved by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), though its implementation has faced challenges and accusations of violation.

Diplomatic Framework

PRC's Conditions

Beijing has consistently set two primary conditions for re-establishing formal diplomatic relations:

Non-interference by the Holy See in China's internal religious affairs.
Adherence to the PRC's "One China" principle, necessitating the severance of diplomatic ties with the government in Taipei.

Holy See's Stance

The Holy See has indicated that any relocation of its Apostolic Nunciature (embassy) to Beijing would require robust guarantees of religious freedom for Catholics in China. The central issue remains the procedure for appointing bishops, which the Vatican asserts is the exclusive prerogative of the Pope, a position that conflicts with the PRC's insistence on state control via the Chinese Catholic Patriotic Association.

Bishop Appointments

The appointment of bishops is the most critical point of negotiation. The PRC mandates that bishops be elected by Chinese Catholics through the state-sanctioned Chinese Catholic Patriotic Association, effectively placing the Communist Party in ultimate control. The Vatican, bound by canon law, views such state-controlled ordinations as valid but illicit, though it has historically refrained from announcing excommunications for those involved, preferring a path of dialogue and reconciliation.

Historical Trajectory

Early Relations & Break

Following the Communist victory in the Chinese Civil War in 1949, the PRC severed diplomatic relations with the Holy See in 1951. This followed Pope Pius XII's directive forbidding Chinese Catholics from joining or participating in CCP activities. The Apostolic Nuncio was subsequently deported, marking a definitive break.

1950s: The PRC established the Chinese Catholic Patriotic Association, promoting an independent church structure.
1951: Diplomatic relations were severed, and the Apostolic Nuncio was expelled.
Post-1950s: The Catholic community in China bifurcated into the state-sanctioned "Patriotic Church" and the "Underground Church" loyal to the Pope.

Vatican Diplomacy

In the post-Cuban Missile Crisis era, the Vatican adopted an "Ostpolitik" approach, reducing anti-communist rhetoric and seeking engagement with communist states. This shift aimed to improve access for sacraments and public church life. Pope John Paul II signaled a desire for better relations, advocating for Chinese Catholics to be "authentically Chinese" while remaining Christian, though his later actions, such as canonizing Boxer Rebellion martyrs, drew protests from Beijing.

John Paul II: Permitted the Underground Church to ordain bishops without Vatican approval (1978), later apologized for perceived historical disrespect by Christians in China (2001).
Benedict XVI: Issued an open letter (2007) affirming one Catholic Church in China and clarifying the illicit nature of state-appointed bishops, while removing prior Vatican permissions for the Underground Church to appoint bishops independently.

Towards Normalization

Efforts towards rapprochement intensified in the 21st century, marked by papal visits to Asia where airspace was opened by China, and diplomatic exchanges. The election of Pope Francis in 2013 further signaled a desire for improved relations, with the Pope expressing a wish to visit China.

2013: Pope Francis expressed a desire to visit China and improve relations.
2014: China opened its airspace for the papal plane, and the Pope sent a telegram to the Chinese people.
2018: The provisional agreement on bishop appointments was signed, a landmark step despite ongoing controversies.

The 2018 Agreement

Provisional Accord

In September 2018, the Holy See and the PRC signed a historic provisional agreement concerning the appointment of bishops. While the exact text remains undisclosed, the agreement aims to facilitate communication and improve relations, allowing the Pope to appoint bishops who are also recognized by Chinese authorities. This was seen as a significant, albeit controversial, step towards potential normalization.

Renewals and Violations

The agreement has been renewed multiple times, including in October 2020 and October 2022, each for two-year terms, and most recently in October 2024 for four years. However, the implementation has been fraught with difficulties. The Vatican has accused the PRC government of violating the terms, citing unilateral appointments of bishops to dioceses not recognized by the Holy See, and the installation of bishops without prior Vatican consultation.

Bishop Appointments: China recommends candidates, and the Pope has the authority to veto.
Reconciliation: Francis approved previously appointed bishops, withdrawing censures, while also demoting some Underground Church bishops.
Loyalty Pledge: Following the agreement, the Chinese Catholic Church pledged loyalty to the CCP.
Concerns: Critics, like Cardinal Joseph Zen, argued the agreement "sold out" the Church. Incidents of shrine destruction and unilateral appointments have raised further concerns about Beijing's adherence to the accord.

Pastoral vs. Political

Vatican officials described the agreement as "pastoral, not political," intended to ensure that faithful Catholics have bishops in communion with Rome while also being recognized by Chinese authorities. Pope Francis's message to Chinese Catholics emphasized the importance of being good citizens and contributing to societal harmony, while also allowing for constructive criticism rooted in faith.

Further Context

Audio Resources

Explore discussions on the complexities of the Vatican-China relationship:

Is Pope Francis ‘betraying’ China’s Catholics? 🎧 (BBC World Service, 22 August 2024)

Teacher's Corner

Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio

Edit and Print Materials from this study in the wiki2web studio

Click here to open the "China U2013holy See Relations" Wiki2Web Studio curriculum kit

Use the free Wiki2web Studio to generate printable flashcards, worksheets, exams, and export your materials as a web page or an interactive game.

True or False?

Test Your Knowledge!

Gamer's Corner

Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?

Learn about china_u2013holy_see_relations while playing the wiki2web Clarity Challenge game.

Unlock the mystery image and prove your knowledge by earning trophies. This simple game is addictively fun and is a great way to learn!

Play now

Explore More Topics

Discover other topics to study!

candlewood lake

paul feyerabend

little brown and company

lászló palkovics

president of the philippines

jake collier

delaware lackawanna and western railroad

freiburg school

alliance ohio

east-west industrial corridor highway arunachal pradesh

References

A full list of references for this article are available at the China–Holy See relations Wikipedia page

Feedback & Support

To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.

Disclaimer

Important Notice

This content has been generated by an AI and is intended for informational and educational purposes only. It is based on publicly available data from Wikipedia and may not reflect the most current developments or nuances of the complex relationship between the Holy See and the People's Republic of China.

This is not diplomatic or political advice. The information provided herein should not be considered a substitute for professional analysis or consultation with experts in international relations, diplomacy, or religious affairs. Always consult official sources and qualified professionals for accurate and up-to-date information.

The creators of this page are not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for any actions taken based on the information provided.

Diplomatic Currents

💡 Dive in with Flashcard Learning! 💡

Current Relations 🤝

🚫 No Official Ties

⚖️ Strained Dynamics

🤝 Provisional Agreement

Diplomatic Framework 📜

🇨🇳 PRC's Conditions

🇻🇦 Holy See's Stance

⛪ Bishop Appointments

Historical Trajectory 🗓️

🇨🇳➡️🇻🇦 Early Relations & Break

🇻🇦➡️🇨🇳 Vatican Diplomacy

📈 Towards Normalization

The 2018 Agreement ✍️

📜 Provisional Accord

🔄 Renewals and Violations

🕊️ Pastoral vs. Political

Further Context 🔗

📚 See Also

🔊 Audio Resources

Teacher's Corner 🧑‍🏫

Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio

True or False? 🤔

❓ Test Your Knowledge! ❓

Gamer's Corner 🎮

Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?

Explore More Topics

📜 Discover other topics to study!

References

📜 References

Feedback & Support 👍

To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.

Disclaimer ⚠️

📜 Important Notice

Dive in with Flashcard Learning!

Current Relations

No Official Ties

Strained Dynamics

Provisional Agreement

Diplomatic Framework

PRC's Conditions

Holy See's Stance

Bishop Appointments

Historical Trajectory

Early Relations & Break

Vatican Diplomacy

Towards Normalization

The 2018 Agreement

Provisional Accord

Renewals and Violations

Pastoral vs. Political

Further Context

See Also

Audio Resources

Teacher's Corner

True or False?

Test Your Knowledge!

Gamer's Corner

Discover other topics to study!

References

Feedback & Support

Disclaimer

Important Notice