What is the fundamental concept behind green imperialism?

Green imperialism, also known by terms like eco-imperialism, environmental imperialism, or eco-colonialism, is a critical perspective that views Western nations' influence on developing countries as a strategy to interfere in their internal affairs under the guise of environmentalism. It suggests that environmental concerns are used as a justification for external control or pressure.

What are some alternative names or related terms used to describe green imperialism?

Besides green imperialism, related terms include eco-imperialism, environmental imperialism, and eco-colonialism. These terms all convey a similar idea of external influence or control exerted under the banner of environmental protection.

How did the term "green imperialism" originate in relation to the Brundtland Commission?

The term "green imperialism" was first articulated by Helge Ole Bergesen in 1988. It was used to describe the skeptical reaction of Third World elites to the Brundtland Commission's report, suggesting that the report's recommendations were perceived as externally imposed strategies rather than collaborative solutions.

How does Richard Grove's interpretation of "green imperialism" differ from that of Helge Ole Bergesen and Deepak Lal?

While Bergesen and Lal used "green imperialism" to denote a contemporary Western strategy influencing developing nations, Richard Grove's 1995 book uses the term to explore the historical impact of idealized visions of tropical islands on European scientists, which contributed to the origins of early environmentalism. Grove's focus is on historical influences, whereas Bergesen and Lal's is on modern political dynamics.

When did the terms "environmental colonialism" or "eco-colonialism" first emerge, and what were they associated with?

The terms "environmental colonialism" or "eco-colonialism" began appearing around 1989, particularly in discussions concerning debt-for-nature swaps. These terms highlighted concerns that environmental protection initiatives, regardless of their intent, could be perceived as intrusive and imperialistic actions.

What negative impacts have been linked to the establishment of national parks in some African countries?

In certain cases, the establishment of national parks in Africa has resulted in negative consequences for local populations, including impoverishment and displacement. This demonstrates a potential conflict between conservation efforts and the rights and livelihoods of indigenous communities.

How did the meaning of "eco-imperialism" evolve from Alfred Crosby's concept to Paul Driessen's usage?

Initially, "eco-imperialism" was an abbreviation for Alfred Crosby's concept of ecological imperialism, focusing on the environmental consequences of interference in other countries. However, following Paul Driessen's 2003 book, the term's meaning shifted to describe interference that harms a nation's economy under the guise of environmental protection.

How was environmentalism portrayed in media coverage during the 1999 Battle of Seattle?

During the 1999 Battle of Seattle, media coverage frequently framed environmentalism as a new manifestation of imperialism. This portrayal suggested that affluent, developed nations were imposing their environmental standards and priorities onto developing countries.

What is the core criticism regarding developed countries imposing their environmental preferences on developing nations?

The central criticism is that developed countries impose their environmental preferences and priorities on developing nations, which can obstruct the latter's economic development. This is seen as a way for richer nations to dictate environmental policies without fully considering the developmental needs and contexts of poorer countries.

What was Malaysia's Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad's response to European boycotts of Malaysian timber?

Malaysia's Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad opposed European boycotts of Malaysian timber, asserting that the country needed to export wood for foreign exchange to acquire essential goods. He viewed these boycotts as an imposition reflecting colonial attitudes.

How did the Federal Land Development Authority (FELDA) describe the European Union's ban on palm oil in biofuels?

FELDA characterized the European Union's ban on palm oil in biofuels as "economic colonisation." They argued that this ban, aimed at halting deforestation, echoed historical colonial practices where dominant powers imposed their rules from afar.

Why did Germany label French proposals for carbon tariffs as "eco-imperialism" in 2009?

In 2009, Germany described French proposals for carbon tariffs as "eco-imperialism." This designation likely stemmed from the concern that such tariffs could disproportionately impact the exports of developing countries, potentially hindering their economic growth and competitiveness.

What opposition did greenhouse tariffs face from developing countries like India and China?

Developing nations, including India and China, strongly opposed greenhouse tariffs. They argued that these tariffs would negatively affect their exports and represented a form of hidden protectionism by developed countries, designed to maintain their economic advantages.

How has the European Union's regulation of biofuels been viewed in the context of eco-imperialism?

The European Union's regulations promoting certain sustainable biofuels, while intended to advance environmental goals, have been criticized as extending beyond the EU's jurisdiction. This extraterritorial application has led to concerns about eco-imperialism, suggesting an imposition of standards on other regions.

What concern did a Japanese commissioner express regarding international calls for sustainable whaling?

A Japanese commissioner, Joji Morishita, voiced concerns that international pressure regarding whaling, particularly from the International Whaling Commission, was perceived in Japan as a form of "eco-imperialism." This suggests a feeling that external bodies were dictating cultural practices and dietary choices.

What criticism was directed at the World Bank loan for the Medupi Power Station?

The World Bank's loan of $3.05 billion for the Medupi Power Station faced criticism for supporting increased global greenhouse gas emissions. The loan was intended for a large coal-fired power plant, raising environmental concerns.

What was the counter-argument regarding the Medupi Power Station loan and industrial development?

The counter-argument presented was that without the Medupi Power Station, industrial development in the country would face significant limitations. This highlights the tension between environmental protection goals and the perceived necessity of industrial growth for economic advancement.

How has Joe Biden's "Executive Order on Tackling the Climate Crisis at Home and Abroad" been described by some sources?

Joe Biden's "Executive Order on Tackling the Climate Crisis at Home and Abroad" has been characterized by some sources, such as Asia Times, as "green imperialism." It has also been described as a veiled protectionist policy intended to shield American jobs from competition with goods produced under less stringent environmental regulations.

How is eco-imperialism related to neoliberalism?

Eco-imperialism is often described as a combination of global environmental agendas and broader neoliberal agendas. This suggests that the promotion of environmental policies can be intertwined with economic liberalization and market-driven approaches that may align with neoliberal principles.

What does eco-imperialism imply regarding the commodification of Earth's resources?

Eco-imperialism is perceived to lead to the commodification of all of Earth's resources. This means that natural assets are increasingly treated as commodities within market systems, potentially for environmental purposes, which can be part of a broader neoliberal agenda.

What is "green grabbing," and how does it relate to the commodification of nature?

"Green grabbing" refers to the process of acquiring or controlling natural resources for environmental goals, often framed as "selling nature to save it." It involves the commodification of nature, where land or resources are converted into marketable assets, potentially impacting local communities and traditional resource use.

What example is provided for "green grabbing" in relation to the Ouarzazate Solar Power Station?

The Ouarzazate Solar Power Station in Morocco is cited as an example of "green grabbing." This project was reportedly constructed on pasture land without the informed consent of surrounding communities, and it exports energy to Europe, illustrating how environmental initiatives can involve land acquisition and benefit external entities.

What is the critical perspective on environmentalism's role in hindering the economic development of developing countries?

Critics argue that environmentalism can be used as a pretext to hinder the economic development of developing countries. They contend that external environmental priorities may prevent these nations from utilizing resources, such as fossil fuels, which they view as essential for poverty reduction and industrial growth.

What argument do critics make about the role of fossil fuels in developing nations?

Critics argue that fossil fuels are crucial for developing nations to lift entire populations out of poverty and achieve industrialization. They believe that alternative energy sources are not yet sufficiently viable for this purpose and that restricting access to fossil fuels impedes necessary economic progress.

What was the stance of developing nations like Brazil, India, and Singapore on linking global trade with pollution controls in 1994?

In 1994, developing nations including Brazil, India, and Singapore opposed linking global trade agreements with pollution controls. They viewed such measures as a form of hidden protectionism that would disadvantage their exports and maintain the economic advantages of developed countries.

How have environmentalist NGOs' agendas been described by certain countries in 2022?

In 2022, countries such as Japan, Peru, South Africa, Kenya, and Bolivia described the agendas of environmentalist NGOs as neo-colonialism and eco-imperialism. This reflects a perception that these organizations impose external values and agendas on sovereign nations.

What was Anil Agarwal's critique of the World Resources Institute's 1990 study on global warming?

Anil Agarwal criticized a 1990 World Resources Institute study that attributed global warming responsibility primarily to developing countries. He deemed the study flawed, politically motivated, and unjust, believing it worsened the North-South divide by unfairly blaming poorer nations.

Whom did Anil Agarwal blame for global warming in his 1991 paper?

In his 1991 paper, Anil Agarwal identified the overconsumption patterns of the United States as the cause of global warming. He presented this as an instance of environmental colonialism, where the actions of a wealthy nation have significant global environmental consequences.

What did a 1990s survey reveal about the perception of debt-for-nature swaps?

A 1990s worldwide survey, "Bicycles, Yes — Cheap Shoes, No," found that 66% of participants did not consider debt-for-nature swaps to be a form of eco-colonialism. This indicates that a majority of respondents did not view these financial arrangements as imperialistic.

How is Michael Shellenberger's book "Apocalypse Never" discussed in relation to environmental colonialism?

Michael Shellenberger's book "Apocalypse Never: Why Environmental Alarmism Hurts Us All" addresses environmental colonialism. John Tierney, reviewing the book, noted that Shellenberger effectively argues his case, incorporating data, policy analysis, and historical accounts, including examples of people in poorer nations affected by "environmental colonialism."

What is the core meaning of "eco-imperialism" as used by Paul Driessen?

Paul Driessen, in his book "Eco-Imperialism: Green Power Black Death," defines "eco-imperialism" as interference that negatively impacts a country's economy, conducted under the banner of environmental improvement. This definition contrasts with earlier concepts of ecological imperialism.

What historical impact did "utopian tropical islands" have, according to Richard Grove's "Green Imperialism"?

According to Richard Grove's "Green Imperialism," the concept refers to how idealized notions of tropical islands influenced European scientists, contributing to the emergence of early environmentalism. This highlights a historical link between European perceptions and the development of environmental thought.

What specific accusation did FELDA make against the European Union regarding palm oil regulations?

The Federal Land Development Authority (FELDA) accused the European Union of "economic colonisation" due to its ban on palm oil in biofuels. FELDA viewed this ban as an imposition reflecting historical colonial attitudes.

What is the "green grabbing" concept, and what does it entail?

Green grabbing is the term used for the commodification of nature for environmental objectives, often summarized as "selling nature to save it." It involves the acquisition or control of natural resources, such as land for conservation or renewable energy projects, which can sometimes lead to the displacement of local communities or alter traditional resource use.

How is the term "eco-imperialism" used as a derogatory epithet?

The term "eco-imperialism" is often used pejoratively to criticize policies or actions perceived as external interference, particularly by developed nations or international bodies towards developing countries. It frames environmental initiatives as attempts at control or exploitation rather than genuine cooperation.

What did Anil Agarwal argue about the North-South divide in relation to global warming?

Anil Agarwal argued that studies attributing global warming primarily to developing countries unfairly exacerbated the North-South divide. He believed such studies, like one from the World Resources Institute, were politically motivated and ignored the role of overconsumption in wealthier nations.

What is the perceived connection between environmentalism and hindering economic development in developing nations?

Critics perceive environmentalism as a potential obstacle to the economic development of developing nations. They argue that external environmental priorities can prevent these countries from utilizing resources, such as fossil fuels, which they consider vital for poverty reduction and industrial growth.

What does the "selling nature to save it" phrase imply in the context of environmental goals?

The phrase "selling nature to save it" relates to the commodification of nature for environmental purposes. It suggests a strategy where natural resources or ecosystems are treated as market assets to fund conservation, which can be associated with practices like green grabbing.

What was the core argument made by developing nations like Brazil, India, and Singapore against linking trade with pollution controls?

Developing nations such as Brazil, India, and Singapore argued that linking global trade with pollution controls constituted hidden protectionism. They believed such measures would disadvantage their exports, thereby preserving economic advantages for developed countries and limiting opportunities for poorer nations.

What is the significance of the Ouarzazate Solar Power Station example in discussions of green grabbing?

The Ouarzazate Solar Power Station is cited as an example of green grabbing because it was reportedly built on pasture land without informing local communities, and its energy is partially exported to Europe. This illustrates how large-scale environmental projects can involve land acquisition and benefit external markets.

Green Imperialism Wiki: Green Imperialism: A Critical Examination of Environmental Policy and Global Power Dynamics

Dive in with Flashcard Learning!

When you are ready...
🎮 Play the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge Game🎮

Defining Green Imperialism

The Core Accusation

Green imperialism, also referred to as eco-imperialism, eco-colonialism, or environmental imperialism, is a critical perspective that frames environmentalism as a strategy employed by Western nations to exert influence over the internal affairs of developing countries. This perspective suggests that environmental agendas are used to impose specific policies and priorities, often to the detriment of the economic development of these nations.

The Skeptical Viewpoint

From this critical standpoint, environmentalism is seen not merely as a movement for ecological protection but as a vehicle for the powerful to dictate terms to the less powerful. It implies that the environmental preferences and priorities of developed nations are being imposed upon developing countries, potentially disregarding their unique circumstances and developmental needs.

Etymology and Origins

Early Conceptualizations

The term "green imperialism" gained traction in the late 20th century. Helge Ole Bergesen first used the term in 1988 to describe the perceived skepticism of Third World elites towards the Brundtland Commission's report. Deepak Lal later popularized the term in his 1999 book, Green Imperialism: A Prescription for Misery and War in the World's Poorest Countries, using it to denote a detrimental Western strategy. Conversely, Richard Grove's 1995 work, Green Imperialism: Colonial Expansion, Tropical Island Edens and the Origins of Environmentalism 1600–1860, uses the term to describe the influence of utopian tropical environments on early European environmental thought.

Eco-Colonialism and Debt-for-Nature

The related terms "environmental colonialism" and "eco-colonialism" emerged around 1989, often in discussions surrounding debt-for-nature swaps. Concerns were raised that these programs, while potentially well-intentioned, could be perceived as intrusive and imperialistic. Furthermore, the establishment of national parks in Africa has, in some instances, led to the displacement and impoverishment of local populations, fueling these perceptions of eco-colonialism.

Semantic Shifts

The term "eco-imperialism" initially referred to Alfred Crosby's concept of ecological imperialism, which described the environmental impact of colonial expansion. However, its meaning evolved following Paul Driessen's 2003 book, Eco-Imperialism: Green Power Black Death. Driessen's usage shifted the focus to economic impacts, defining eco-imperialism as interference that degrades economies in the name of environmental improvement, contrasting with Crosby's emphasis on environmental degradation.

Key Arguments and Examples

Trade and Economic Policies

Critics argue that environmental regulations imposed by developed nations can act as barriers to trade for developing countries. For instance, European Union proposals for carbon tariffs and regulations on palm oil biofuels have been met with accusations of "economic colonisation" from countries like Malaysia, which rely on these exports for foreign exchange. Mahathir Mohamad, then Prime Minister of Malaysia, argued that such measures hinder necessary economic activity and reflect colonial attitudes.

Development vs. Environmentalism

A central tension lies in the perceived conflict between environmental protection and economic development. Some argue that fossil fuels are essential for lifting populations out of poverty, and that environmentalist agendas hinder this progress. Developing nations, including Brazil, India, and Singapore, have historically opposed linking global trade with pollution controls, viewing them as protectionist measures that preserve jobs in developed countries while limiting opportunities for poorer nations.

Global Initiatives and Critiques

International initiatives, such as U.S. President Joe Biden's executive orders on climate, have been described by outlets like Asian Times as "green imperialism" and protectionist policies aimed at shielding American jobs. Similarly, controversies surrounding whaling, where Japan faced international pressure, have been framed by Japanese officials as a form of "eco-imperialism." The World Bank's loan for South Africa's Medupi Power Station also drew criticism for supporting emissions, with opponents arguing it limited industrial development.

The Nexus with Neoliberalism

Intertwined Agendas

Eco-imperialism is often analyzed as being intertwined with broader neoliberal global agendas. This perspective suggests that environmental goals are pursued in ways that promote the commodification of natural resources, a hallmark of neoliberal economic policies. This process, sometimes termed "green grabbing," involves privatizing or controlling natural assets for environmental objectives, potentially displacing local communities and traditional resource users.

Commodification of Nature

The concept of "selling nature to save it" encapsulates this trend. Projects like the Ouarzazate Solar Power Station in Morocco, while promoting renewable energy, have been criticized by groups like the Committee for the Abolition of Illegitimate Debt for being built on pasture land without community consultation and for exporting energy to Europe. This highlights concerns about how environmental initiatives can serve external economic interests and lead to the appropriation of resources.

Political Debates and Perspectives

Hindering Development

Critical voices often contend that environmentalism serves as a pretext to impede the economic progress of developing nations. They argue that alternative energy sources are not yet viable replacements for fossil fuels, which are seen as crucial for poverty reduction. This perspective views environmental regulations as a means for developed countries to maintain their economic advantages and job markets.

Accusations of Neo-colonialism

The agendas of environmental non-governmental organizations (NGOs) are frequently labeled as neo-colonialism and eco-imperialism by representatives from various countries, including Japan, Peru, South Africa, Kenya, and Bolivia. This framing suggests that these organizations, often funded by Western entities, promote policies that benefit the Global North at the expense of the Global South.

Survey Data and Nuance

While the critique of eco-imperialism is significant, public opinion surveys have indicated varying levels of agreement. A 1990s survey by WorldPaper found that a majority (66%) of participants did not perceive debt-for-nature swaps as eco-colonialism. Additionally, some analyses, like Michael Shellenberger's Apocalypse Never, argue that environmental alarmism can itself be detrimental, blending policy analysis with historical accounts of developing countries suffering from perceived "environmental colonialism."

Related Concepts and Criticisms

Broader Context

The concept of green imperialism intersects with several related ideas that critique power dynamics and exploitation in global relations. These include:

Cultural Imperialism: The imposition of one culture's values and practices on another.
Environmental Justice: The fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people regardless of race, color, national origin, or income with respect to the development, implementation, and enforcement of environmental laws, regulations, and policies.
Environmental Racism: The disproportionate impact of environmental hazards on people of color.
White Savior Complex: A critique of individuals from dominant groups who intervene in the lives of marginalized groups, often with paternalistic or self-serving motives.

Understanding green imperialism requires considering these interconnected critiques of power, equity, and environmental governance on a global scale.

Teacher's Corner

Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio

Edit and Print Materials from this study in the wiki2web studio

Click here to open the "Green Imperialism" Wiki2Web Studio curriculum kit

Use the free Wiki2web Studio to generate printable flashcards, worksheets, exams, and export your materials as a web page or an interactive game.

True or False?

Test Your Knowledge!

Gamer's Corner

Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?

Learn about green_imperialism while playing the wiki2web Clarity Challenge game.

Unlock the mystery image and prove your knowledge by earning trophies. This simple game is addictively fun and is a great way to learn!

Play now

Explore More Topics

Discover other topics to study!

south carolina supreme court

trailways transportation system

united nations mission of observers in prevlaka

References

A full list of references for this article are available at the Green imperialism Wikipedia page

Feedback & Support

To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.

Disclaimer

Important Notice

This page was generated by an Artificial Intelligence and is intended for informational and educational purposes only. The content is based on a snapshot of publicly available data from Wikipedia and may not be entirely accurate, complete, or up-to-date.

This is not political or economic advice. The information provided on this website is not a substitute for professional consultation on international relations, political science, or economic policy. Always consult with qualified experts for specific analyses and guidance.

The creators of this page are not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for any actions taken based on the information provided herein.

The Verdant Veil

💡 Dive in with Flashcard Learning! 💡

Defining Green Imperialism 🌍

⚖️ The Core Accusation

🤔 The Skeptical Viewpoint

Etymology and Origins 📚

📜 Early Conceptualizations

🔗 Eco-Colonialism and Debt-for-Nature

🔄 Semantic Shifts

Key Arguments and Examples 📈

💰 Trade and Economic Policies

🏭 Development vs. Environmentalism

🏛️ Global Initiatives and Critiques

The Nexus with Neoliberalism 🔗

🌐 Intertwined Agendas

🌳 Commodification of Nature

Political Debates and Perspectives 🗣️

🚫 Hindering Development

🤝 Accusations of Neo-colonialism

❓ Survey Data and Nuance

Related Concepts and Criticisms 🔗

🧩 Broader Context

Teacher's Corner 🧑‍🏫

Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio

True or False? 🤔

❓ Test Your Knowledge! ❓

Gamer's Corner 🎮

Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?

Explore More Topics

📜 Discover other topics to study!

References

📜 References

Feedback & Support 👍

To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.

Disclaimer ⚠️

📜 Important Notice

Dive in with Flashcard Learning!

Defining Green Imperialism

The Core Accusation

The Skeptical Viewpoint

Etymology and Origins

Early Conceptualizations

Eco-Colonialism and Debt-for-Nature

Semantic Shifts

Key Arguments and Examples

Trade and Economic Policies

Development vs. Environmentalism

Global Initiatives and Critiques

The Nexus with Neoliberalism

Intertwined Agendas

Commodification of Nature

Political Debates and Perspectives

Hindering Development

Accusations of Neo-colonialism

Survey Data and Nuance

Related Concepts and Criticisms

Broader Context

Teacher's Corner

True or False?

Test Your Knowledge!

Gamer's Corner

Discover other topics to study!

References

Feedback & Support

Disclaimer

Important Notice