Who was John FitzGibbon, 1st Earl of Clare, and what were his primary roles in Irish politics?

John FitzGibbon, 1st Earl of Clare, was an Anglo-Irish politician who held significant positions in Ireland. He served as the Attorney-General for Ireland from 1783 to 1789 and subsequently as the Lord Chancellor of Ireland from 1789 until his death in 1802. He is a notable and controversial figure in Irish history due to his staunch opposition to Catholic Emancipation and his advocacy for the Act of Union.

What were the key political stances and controversies associated with John FitzGibbon, 1st Earl of Clare?

John FitzGibbon was known as a hardliner for the Protestant Ascendancy and an opponent of Catholic Emancipation. He also strongly opposed the independent Irish Parliament's Constitution of 1782 and was a significant advocate for the Act of Union, which merged the Irish and British parliaments. His political career was marked by deep divisions, particularly concerning the rights of the Catholic majority in Ireland.

What significant role is attributed to John FitzGibbon regarding King George III and Catholic Emancipation?

It is suggested that John FitzGibbon may have been the first person to advise King George III that granting Royal Assent to any form of Catholic Emancipation would violate the King's coronation oath. This assertion played a crucial role in solidifying opposition to Catholic rights for many years.

Describe the early life and education of John FitzGibbon.

John FitzGibbon was born in 1748 near Donnybrook, Dublin. His father, John FitzGibbon, had converted from Catholicism to the state religion to pursue a legal career and amassed considerable wealth. John FitzGibbon received his education at Trinity College Dublin and later at Christ Church, Oxford.

Which constituencies did John FitzGibbon represent in the Irish House of Commons, and what other significant office did he hold early in his career?

John FitzGibbon first entered the Irish House of Commons in 1778 representing Dublin University, a seat he held until 1783. He then represented Kilmallock from 1783 until 1790. Additionally, he served as the High Sheriff of County Limerick for the year 1782.

How did John FitzGibbon's peerages evolve over his career?

Upon his appointment as Lord Chancellor in 1789, John FitzGibbon was created Baron FitzGibbon of Lower Connello in the Peerage of Ireland. He was further advanced to Viscount FitzGibbon in 1793 and then created Earl of Clare in 1795, all within the Peerage of Ireland. To gain a seat in the British House of Lords, he was created Baron FitzGibbon of Sidbury in the Peerage of Great Britain in 1799.

What was Lord FitzGibbon's position on the Protestant Ascendancy and Catholic Emancipation?

Lord FitzGibbon was a prominent champion of the Protestant Ascendancy, which was the dominance of the Protestant minority in Ireland. Consequently, he was a staunch opponent of Catholic Emancipation, a movement aimed at ending religious discrimination and civil disabilities against Catholics.

How did John FitzGibbon view the Irish Parliament's Constitution of 1782?

John FitzGibbon held a strong personal and political opposition to the Constitution of 1782, which had established a greater degree of legislative independence for the Irish Parliament. He viewed it negatively, likely seeing it as a challenge to the established order and British authority.

Who was Henry Grattan, and how did FitzGibbon's actions affect Grattan's reform efforts?

Henry Grattan was a prominent Irish politician who advocated for moderate reforms within the Irish Parliament. FitzGibbon was personally and politically opposed to Grattan and was instrumental in defeating Grattan's efforts to reform the Irish tithe system between 1787 and 1789. This system unfairly burdened Irish Catholic farmers with financial support for the minority Anglican Church of Ireland.

What was the context and FitzGibbon's role concerning the Roman Catholic Relief Act of 1793?

FitzGibbon initially opposed the Roman Catholic Relief Act of 1793, which aimed to grant some concessions to Catholics. However, under pressure from William Pitt's government in London, which sought to placate Catholic opinion before potential war with the French Republic, FitzGibbon was persuaded to recommend its acceptance in the Irish House of Lords. This act allowed Catholics to enter professions and hold public office, though not to sit in Parliament.

What was the 'Fitzwilliam episode,' and what role did FitzGibbon allegedly play?

The 'Fitzwilliam episode' refers to the brief tenure of Lord Fitzwilliam as Lord Lieutenant of Ireland in 1795. Fitzwilliam was known for his liberal Whig views and support for Catholic Emancipation. While FitzGibbon was politically opposed to Fitzwilliam, the Lord Lieutenant's recall is debated; Fitzwilliam was likely recalled due to his independent actions and perceived support for immediate Catholic emancipation without explicit British cabinet authorization, rather than solely due to FitzGibbon's opposition.

On what significant issue did Irish Catholics and John FitzGibbon find common ground?

Despite their deep political and religious differences, Irish Catholics and John FitzGibbon apparently agreed on the desirability of a political and economic union between Ireland and Great Britain. This union eventually occurred in 1801, forming the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland.

What was FitzGibbon's specific stance on the Act of Union concerning Catholic concessions?

While FitzGibbon was a strong supporter of the Act of Union, he adamantly refused to link it with Catholic emancipation. He believed that the Union should proceed without any concessions to the Catholic majority, a stance that ultimately prevailed in the final legislation.

What was the immediate consequence of the Act of Union regarding concessions for Ireland's Catholic majority?

The Act of Union, which took effect in 1801, was passed without any significant concessions for Ireland's Catholic majority. FitzGibbon's influence ensured that the union proceeded without addressing the demands for Catholic rights, a situation that persisted for several years.

What controversy surrounds the Earl of Clare's role during the Irish Rebellion of 1798?

The Earl of Clare's role as Lord Chancellor during the 1798 rebellion is contentious. Some accounts suggest he supported harsh policies, including torture and murder, to suppress the rebellion, and that he influenced military affairs. Conversely, other sources, including the *Encyclopædia Britannica*, state he was not inherently cruel and was inclined to mercy in individual cases, while also noting his strong support for repressive policies against Irish Catholics.

How did Lord Clare's actions impact the treatment of captured United Irish leaders versus the common populace during the 1798 rebellion?

While Lord Clare showed leniency towards the largely upper-class leadership of the United Irishmen, sparing their lives in return for confessions and information, the common people faced severe repression. Thousands suffered imprisonment, torture, transportation, and death between 1797 and 1798. This contrast highlights a dual approach to dealing with the rebellion.

What was Lord Clare's reaction to the capture of Wolfe Tone?

Upon the capture of Wolfe Tone, a key leader of the United Irishmen, Lord Clare expressed disgust that Tone was granted a trial. He believed Tone should have been executed immediately upon setting foot in Ireland, indicating his hardline stance against rebel leaders.

What is the apocryphal story regarding Lord Clare's callousness during a parliamentary debate?

An anecdote suggests that when informed during an Irish Parliament debate that innocent people were suffering atrocities during the repression, Lord Clare callously replied, 'Well suppose it were so...' This alleged response reportedly shocked William Pitt the Younger.

What is stated about Lord Clare's reputation as a landlord?

Some accounts suggest Lord Clare was a good, improving landlord to both his Protestant and Catholic tenants. However, there is a lack of substantial evidence regarding his dealings as a landlord, and Irish nationalists point out that his treatment of his own tenants might contrast with his broader policies towards Irish Catholics.

What is the apocryphal story surrounding Lord Clare's funeral?

Lord Clare died in Dublin in 1802 and was buried in St. Peter's Churchyard. Due to his controversial status, his funeral cortege was reportedly the cause of a riot, with a widespread story claiming that dead cats were thrown at his coffin as it left Ely Place.

How did John FitzGibbon's political impact compare between British and Irish history?

John FitzGibbon, the 1st Earl of Clare, made a more significant mark on Irish parliamentary and political history than on British political history. While figures like Henry Grattan and Lord Edward FitzGerald are more widely remembered, FitzGibbon's influence on key events like the Act of Union and the suppression of Catholic rights was profound.

What is considered John FitzGibbon's most significant historical achievement?

FitzGibbon's most significant historical achievement is arguably his success in convincing King George III that granting concessions to Catholics would violate the King's Coronation Oath. This influence significantly delayed Catholic Emancipation, as both the King and his son became staunch opponents of such measures.

How did FitzGibbon's actions affect William Pitt's political career?

FitzGibbon's influence in preventing Catholic emancipation concurrently with the Act of Union contributed to the downfall of Prime Minister William Pitt the Younger. Pitt had staked his reputation on achieving both reforms together, and their separation led to Pitt's resignation.

What was the long-term impact of FitzGibbon's opposition to Catholic Emancipation?

FitzGibbon's successful opposition to Catholic Emancipation delayed the granting of full rights to Catholics until 1829. While he achieved his goal of Union without concessions in the short term, his policies ultimately contributed to conditions that necessitated later reforms, albeit under different political circumstances.

According to Sir Jonah Barrington, what was FitzGibbon's primary motivation and how did his conduct change?

Sir Jonah Barrington assessed FitzGibbon's political conduct as driven by ambition, describing it as 'miserably inconsistent.' Barrington noted that FitzGibbon shifted from advocating for Irish independence in 1781 and proclaiming Ireland a free nation in 1783 to recommending military force to extinguish independence and arguing for Ireland to be a province by 1799 and 1800, respectively. Barrington concluded that FitzGibbon's prejudice often overrode his reason.

What were the successive peerages granted to John FitzGibbon?

John FitzGibbon was granted several peerages throughout his career. He became Baron FitzGibbon in 1789, Viscount FitzGibbon in 1793, and Earl of Clare in 1795, all within the Peerage of Ireland. Later, in 1799, he was created Baron FitzGibbon of Sidbury in the Peerage of Great Britain.

Describe the coronet and coat of arms associated with the Earl of Clare.

The coronet of the Earl of Clare is that of a British Earl. His coat of arms features an escutcheon described as Ermine a saltire gules on a chief or, three annulets of the second. The crest is a boar passant azure tusked and bristled or, and the supporters are a lion or on the dexter side and a tiger or on the sinister side.

What is the motto of the Earl of Clare, and what does it mean?

The motto associated with the Earl of Clare is 'Nil admirari.' This Latin phrase translates to 'Marvel at nothing,' suggesting a stoic or perhaps detached perspective.

What was the nature of the tithe system in Ireland that FitzGibbon opposed reforming?

The tithe system in Ireland, which FitzGibbon opposed reforming, required Irish Catholic farmers, and other non-Anglican farmers, to financially support the minority Anglican Church of Ireland. This was a significant source of resentment and financial burden for the majority population.

What is the significance of the portrait of John FitzGibbon by Gilbert Stuart mentioned in the infobox?

The infobox mentions a portrait of John FitzGibbon, 1st Earl of Clare, painted by Gilbert Stuart. This artwork serves as a visual representation of the historical figure, likely capturing his likeness during his prominent political career.

What was FitzGibbon's view on the potential for uniting Protestant, Catholic, and Dissenter groups in Ireland?

FitzGibbon believed that sectarianism could be used to divide potential rebels and prevent the United Irishmen's goal of uniting Protestants, Catholics, and Dissenters. He actively promoted the idea that rebellions were primarily 'popish' to sow discord and maintain control.

What was the ultimate fate of the Act of Union's goal regarding Catholic concessions, according to the text?

While FitzGibbon succeeded in passing the Act of Union without immediate Catholic concessions, his long-term view ultimately lost out. Subsequent British Cabinets were compelled to grant full rights to Catholics in 1829, demonstrating a shift in policy over time.

How did FitzGibbon's actions influence the political landscape concerning the Union and Catholic Emancipation?

FitzGibbon's firm stance against linking Catholic Emancipation with the Act of Union had significant consequences. It led to the Union's passage without concessions, contributed to Pitt's resignation, and solidified opposition to Catholic rights for decades, thereby shaping both Irish and British political history.

John Fitzgibbon 1st Earl Of Clare Wiki: John FitzGibbon: Architect of Union, Arbiter of Ireland

Dive in with Flashcard Learning!

When you are ready...
🎮 Play the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge Game🎮

Biography

Early Life and Education

Born in 1748 near Donnybrook, Dublin, John FitzGibbon was the son of John FitzGibbon, a lawyer who converted from Catholicism to the established church to advance his career, amassing considerable wealth. FitzGibbon received his higher education at Trinity College Dublin and Christ Church, Oxford. He entered the Irish House of Commons in 1778, representing Dublin University until 1783, and later Kilmallock from 1783 to 1790. He also served as High Sheriff of County Limerick in 1782.

Peerage and Titles

FitzGibbon's ascent through the peerage was significant. Upon his appointment as Lord Chancellor of Ireland in 1789, he was created Baron FitzGibbon of Lower Connello in the Peerage of Ireland. He was further elevated to Viscount FitzGibbon in 1793 and then Earl of Clare in 1795. To secure a seat in the British House of Lords, he was created Baron FitzGibbon of Sidbury in the Peerage of Great Britain in 1799. His titles reflected his growing influence and status within the British and Irish aristocracy.

Legal and Political Career

Attorney General and Lord Chancellor

FitzGibbon's legal acumen propelled him to high office. He served as Attorney-General for Ireland from 1783 to 1789, a critical period of political transition. Subsequently, he held the esteemed position of Lord Chancellor of Ireland from 1789 until his death in 1802. In this capacity, he presided over the Irish House of Lords and wielded considerable influence over legal and political matters.

A summary of his significant governmental and parliamentary roles:

Office	Constituency/Jurisdiction	Term	Preceded By	Succeeded By
Member of Parliament	Dublin University	1778–1783	John Finlay, William Christmas	Laurence Parsons, Arthur Browne
Attorney General for Ireland	Ireland	1783–1789	Barry Yelverton	Arthur Wolfe
Member of Parliament	Kilmallock	1783–1790	John Armstrong	Charles Bury, John Armstrong
Lord Chancellor of Ireland	Ireland	1789–1802	Viscount Lifford	John Freeman-Mitford
Baron FitzGibbon (Ireland)	Peerage of Ireland	1789–1802	New Creation	John FitzGibbon (2nd Earl)
Viscount FitzGibbon (Ireland)	Peerage of Ireland	1793–1802	New Creation	John FitzGibbon (2nd Earl)
Earl of Clare (Ireland)	Peerage of Ireland	1795–1802	New Creation	John FitzGibbon (2nd Earl)
Baron FitzGibbon (Great Britain)	Peerage of Great Britain	1799–1802	New Creation	John FitzGibbon (2nd Earl)

Portrait by Gilbert Stuart

A notable portrait of John FitzGibbon, 1st Earl of Clare, was created by the renowned artist Gilbert Stuart. This depiction captures the likeness of a significant figure in late 18th-century Irish politics. While images cannot be displayed here, historical accounts and artistic records confirm its existence, offering a visual representation of the Earl.

Political Stances and Influence

Champion of Protestant Ascendancy

FitzGibbon was a staunch advocate for the Protestant Ascendancy, the ruling Protestant elite in Ireland. He was a vocal opponent of Catholic Emancipation, the movement to end religious discrimination and civil disabilities against Catholics. His stance reflected the prevailing power structures of the time, where the minority Protestant population held significant political and economic dominance over the Catholic majority.

Advocate for the Act of Union

FitzGibbon was an early and fervent proponent of the Act of Union, which proposed the political and economic integration of Ireland with Great Britain. He argued passionately for this union, viewing it as a means to elevate Ireland's status within the global political landscape. His efforts were instrumental in the eventual passage of the Act in 1800, which dissolved the Irish Parliament and created the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland.

In a speech to the Irish House of Lords on 10 February 1800, Lord FitzGibbon elucidated his point of view on union:

I hope and feel as becomes a true Irishman, for the dignity and independence of my country, and therefore I would elevate her to her proper station, in the rank of civilised nations. I wish to advance her from the degraded post of mercenary province, to the proud station of an integral and governing member of the greatest empire in the world.

Tithe System Opposition

As Lord Chancellor, FitzGibbon was responsible for defeating efforts to reform the Irish tithe system. This system, in place from 1787 to 1789, compelled Irish Catholic farmers, along with other non-Anglican denominations, to financially support the minority Church of Ireland. These tithes remained a significant point of contention and were only fully repealed decades later with the disestablishment of the Church of Ireland.

Role in the 1798 Rebellion

Hardline Policies and Repression

The Earl of Clare's role during the Irish Rebellion of 1798 is a subject of historical debate. Some accounts suggest he supported severe measures, including torture and massacre, to quell the uprising. Others contend he was not directly involved in military affairs and was inclined towards mercy in individual cases. However, historical consensus indicates he was a powerful supporter of a repressive policy toward Irish Catholics.

Manipulating Sectarian Divisions

FitzGibbon astutely recognized the utility of sectarianism in dividing the United Irishmen, an organization aiming to unite Protestants, Catholics, and Dissenters. In June 1798, he wrote, "In the North nothing will keep the rebels quiet but the conviction that where treason has broken out the rebellion is merely popish." This strategy aimed to undermine unified opposition by fostering religious mistrust.

Treatment of Rebel Leaders

While the common populace faced harsh repression, FitzGibbon showed leniency towards the captured United Irish leaders. In return for confessions and information, their lives were spared, a stark contrast to the thousands who suffered imprisonment, torture, transportation, and death. His disgust at Wolfe Tone receiving a trial, rather than immediate execution, highlights his uncompromising stance against unrepentant rebels.

Note: The source material includes claims of torture and massacre, marked with '[citation needed]'. These assertions are presented here as reported in the source text.

Landlord Role

Limited Evidence

Information regarding Lord Clare's dealings as a landlord is notably scarce. Some accounts suggest he was a fair, "improving" landlord to his own tenants on estates like Mountshannon, earning him the nickname "Black Jack" FitzGibbon among them. However, this is largely unsubstantiated. Critics point out that any benevolence towards his personal tenants contrasted sharply with his policies affecting the broader Catholic population, diminishing the significance of his landlord role against his political actions.

Legacy and Historical Impact

Controversial Figure

John FitzGibbon remains a deeply controversial figure in Irish history. While lauded by hardline Protestants for his role in preserving Protestant dominance and achieving the Union, he was widely despised by the Catholic majority. His political conduct is described as inconsistent, shifting from advocating Irish independence to supporting its subjugation as a province.

Influence on the Monarchy

FitzGibbon's most significant historical achievement may have been his successful persuasion of King George III that granting concessions to Catholics would violate the monarch's Coronation Oath. This argument significantly bolstered opposition to Catholic Emancipation, delaying its eventual passage until 1829. By influencing the Crown's stance, FitzGibbon profoundly impacted the trajectory of Irish political rights for decades.

Historical Estimates

Sir Jonah Barrington's assessment characterizes FitzGibbon's political career as marked by ambition and prejudice, leading to actions that were "miserably inconsistent." Barrington highlights FitzGibbon's shift from advocating Irish independence to supporting its subjugation, ultimately arguing that his personal ambition and rigid views overshadowed any consistent political philosophy.

Teacher's Corner

Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio

Edit and Print Materials from this study in the wiki2web studio

Click here to open the "John Fitzgibbon 1st Earl Of Clare" Wiki2Web Studio curriculum kit

Use the free Wiki2web Studio to generate printable flashcards, worksheets, exams, and export your materials as a web page or an interactive game.

True or False?

Test Your Knowledge!

Gamer's Corner

Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?

Learn about john_fitzgibbon_1st_earl_of_clare while playing the wiki2web Clarity Challenge game.

Unlock the mystery image and prove your knowledge by earning trophies. This simple game is addictively fun and is a great way to learn!

Play now

Explore More Topics

Discover other topics to study!

tax cut

novi sad

cities of london and westminster uk parliament constituency

list of heads of state of trinidad and tobago

target corporation

bury f.c.

nordstrom

slovak national council

neoclassical architecture

eastern wolf

References

A full list of references for this article are available at the John FitzGibbon, 1st Earl of Clare Wikipedia page

Feedback & Support

To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.

Disclaimer

Important Notice

This page has been generated by an Artificial Intelligence and is intended for educational and informational purposes only. The content is derived from a snapshot of publicly available data and may not be entirely exhaustive, accurate, or up-to-date. Historical interpretations and controversial aspects are presented as found in the source material.

This is not historical or legal advice. The information provided herein is not a substitute for professional historical research, legal consultation, or nuanced political analysis. Always consult primary sources and scholarly works for a comprehensive understanding of historical figures and events. No representation is made as to the accuracy of the information provided, and reliance on it is solely at the user's own risk.

The creators of this page are not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for any actions taken based on the information provided herein.

John FitzGibbon

💡 Dive in with Flashcard Learning! 💡

Biography 👤

📜 Early Life and Education

👑 Peerage and Titles

Legal and Political Career 🏛️

⚖️ Attorney General and Lord Chancellor

🎨 Portrait by Gilbert Stuart

Political Stances and Influence ⚖️

✊ Champion of Protestant Ascendancy

🤝 Advocate for the Act of Union

💰 Tithe System Opposition

Role in the 1798 Rebellion ⚔️

🔥 Hardline Policies and Repression

🗣️ Manipulating Sectarian Divisions

⚖️ Treatment of Rebel Leaders

Landlord Role 🏡

❓ Limited Evidence

Legacy and Historical Impact 📜

🤔 Controversial Figure

👑 Influence on the Monarchy

📉 Historical Estimates

Teacher's Corner 🧑‍🏫

Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio

True or False? 🤔

❓ Test Your Knowledge! ❓

Gamer's Corner 🎮

Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?

Explore More Topics

📜 Discover other topics to study!

References

📜 References

Feedback & Support 👍

To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.

Disclaimer ⚠️

📜 Important Notice

Dive in with Flashcard Learning!

Biography

Early Life and Education

Peerage and Titles

Legal and Political Career

Attorney General and Lord Chancellor

Portrait by Gilbert Stuart

Political Stances and Influence

Champion of Protestant Ascendancy

Advocate for the Act of Union

Tithe System Opposition

Role in the 1798 Rebellion

Hardline Policies and Repression

Manipulating Sectarian Divisions

Treatment of Rebel Leaders

Landlord Role

Limited Evidence

Legacy and Historical Impact

Controversial Figure

Influence on the Monarchy

Historical Estimates

Teacher's Corner

True or False?

Test Your Knowledge!

Gamer's Corner

Discover other topics to study!

References

Feedback & Support

Disclaimer

Important Notice