How does the term 'draft avoidance' differ from 'draft evasion'?

Draft avoidance encompasses practices that adhere to or legally circumvent draft laws to obtain deferments or exemptions. In contrast, draft evasion typically involves illegal actions or outright refusal to comply with the draft.

What is the perspective of draft resisters on their actions compared to draft evasion?

Draft resisters reject the categorization of their actions as evasion or avoidance. They argue that their intent is to confront, rather than evade or avoid, the draft system.

What is a common pejorative term used for draft evaders?

A common pejorative term used for draft evaders is 'draft dodgers'. However, this term has also been used non-judgmentally or even as an honorific, reflecting the varied perceptions of draft evasion.

Is draft evasion a recent phenomenon, or does it have historical roots?

Draft evasion is not a recent phenomenon; laws against certain evasion practices date back thousands of years, and it has been a significant issue in military conflicts throughout the 20th and 21st centuries.

What are some examples of draft evasion practices that comply with the law?

Practices that adhere to the law include claiming conscientious objector status based on sincerely held beliefs, obtaining student deferments, claiming genuine medical or psychological problems, or purchasing legal exemptions where permitted.

What are some examples of draft evasion practices that circumvent or violate the law?

Practices that circumvent the law include feigning or exaggerating medical or psychological problems, obtaining deferments through false claims (e.g., about homosexuality), deliberately self-injuring, bribing officials, or failing military intelligence tests.

What was the 'slacker raid' during World War I in the United States?

During World War I in the US, 'slacker raids' were operations conducted to track down individuals who were avoiding military service, often described as 'slackers'. This period also saw activists arrested under the Espionage Act for speaking out against the draft.

What actions are considered part of 'draft resistance'?

Draft resistance involves overt lawbreaking or communicating conscious opposition to government policy. Examples include declining to register, refusing to report for examinations or induction, burning draft cards, living 'underground', emigrating to avoid service, going to jail, or even resorting to violence against draft officials.

How did conscription create divisions in Canada during World War I and II?

During both World Wars, conscription was a highly divisive issue in Canada, leading to political party collapses and ethnic tensions, particularly between French Canadians who largely opposed conscription and English Canadians who generally accepted it. Riots and draft evasion followed the implementation of draft laws.

What was the Conscription Crisis of 1917 in Canada?

The Conscription Crisis of 1917 in Canada arose from deep divisions over military conscription during World War I. Many Canadians objected for various reasons, including perceived lack of necessity, lack of identification with Britain, or the imposition of unfair burdens on the poor. This led to a significant number of exemption filings and some Canadians leaving the country to avoid conscription.

What was the National Resources Mobilization Act (NRMA) in Canada during WWII?

The NRMA, introduced in 1940, allowed conscripts to serve only within Canada, not overseas. This distinction led to controversy and the pejorative nickname 'Zombies' for NRMA men, who were seen as less committed than those serving abroad. Later in the war, a levy of NRMA men was sent overseas, with many deserting rather than fight abroad.

How is draft evasion practiced differently by social classes in Colombia?

In Colombia, middle-to-upper class individuals typically evade the draft by obtaining college or medical deferments, or by paying bribes for a military ID card. Poorer individuals often avoid showing up for the draft and risk periodic sweeps by the army, facing limited employment prospects if caught without an ID.

What is the nature of the military draft in Eritrea and its connection to emigration?

Eritrea instituted a military draft in 1995, which became open-ended three years later, allowing enlistment for indefinite periods for those under 50. Release often depends on a commander's whim. This policy, combined with the illegality of leaving the country without permission, has led many Eritreans to leave the country primarily to avoid the draft.

What was the 'kapykaarti' or 'metsäkaarti' in Finland during World War II?

The 'kapykaarti' (Pine Cone Guard) or 'metsäkaarti' (Forest Guard) was a term used facetiously in Finland during WWII for draft evaders and deserters who lived as outlaws in the forests. They often lived in groups, sometimes in dugouts, and received support from sympathizers or stole provisions, while being hunted by the army and police.

What were the primary reasons for draft evasion and desertion in Finland during the Continuation War?

During Finland's Continuation War (1941-1944), reasons for draft evasion and desertion included fear of war, weariness, objection to the war as an offensive action, ideological opposition, or support for Communism. Finnish Communists were often detained to prevent them from serving, as previous attempts to conscript them had led to defections.

What was the scale of draft evasion in Napoleonic France, and how was it addressed?

During the Napoleonic Era, draft evasion was a significant problem for the French military, with estimates reaching hundreds of thousands. To combat this, a gendarmerie was assembled to hunt for evaders and deserters, and measures like mandatory passport carrying were enforced.

What are the general grounds for legally evading military service in Israel?

In Israel, military draft can legally be evaded on physical or psychological grounds. Historically, strictly Orthodox Jews also had an exception, though this was challenged in court.

What trends in draft evasion were observed in Israel in the mid-2000s?

By the mid-2000s, Israel saw all-time highs in draft evasion and desertion, with significant percentages of young men and women failing pre-military psychological tests. This period also saw entertainers encouraging draft evasion.

What was the 'Shministim' movement in Israel?

The 'Shministim' was a group of Israeli high school students in 2008 who declared themselves conscientiously opposed to military service. Their stance contrasted with other groups like 'Yesh Gvul' and 'Courage to Refuse', who sometimes negotiated selective refusal, whereas the Shministim advocated for absolute refusal based on pacifist and feminist ideologies.

What was the prevalence of draft evasion in the Soviet Union during the Soviet-Afghan War?

Draft evasion was reportedly 'endemic' in the Soviet Union during the Soviet-Afghan War. The Soviet elite often bribed officials to exempt their sons from deployment or military service altogether.

What was the reported rate of draft evasion in Russia in the mid-2010s?

In the mid-2010s, it was reported that about half of the approximately 150,000 young men called up annually in Russia were evading the draft.

How many Russians fled the country to avoid mobilization in September 2022?

In September 2022, following President Putin's mobilization order, over 600,000 mobilization-eligible Russian citizens reportedly left the country to avoid the draft, with Georgia, Kazakhstan, and Mongolia being primary destinations.

What is the general societal attitude towards draft evasion in South Korea?

South Korean society is reportedly very hostile to draft evasion, viewing it as a severe transgression. Celebrities attempting to evade the draft have faced significant backlash, with one commentator stating it's 'almost like suicide' for them to do so. Evasion can lead to prison sentences and lifelong bans from public life.

What were the penalties for draft evasion in Syria, especially after the civil war began?

In Syria, draft evasion carries stiff punishments, including fines and years of imprisonment. Following the outbreak of the Syrian Civil War in 2011, many draft-age men fled the country or paid to have their names removed from draft rolls to avoid service and the dangers of the conflict.

How has the Tunisian draft system been characterized, and what measures have been taken to address evasion?

The Tunisian draft, in place since 1956, has long been poorly enforced, leading to rampant evasion. To combat this, Tunisia introduced alternative civilian or national service options, but these have not significantly reduced evasion, with a very low percentage of eligible men reporting for service in recent years.

What were the primary reasons for draft evasion in Ukraine in 2015?

In 2015, a significant number of Ukrainians refused military service due to fear of death in the conflict, general opposition to war, or an unwillingness to fight against those they perceived as countrymen.

How many Ukrainian men reportedly fled the country to avoid military service after the Russian invasion?

Following the Russian invasion of Ukraine, which imposed a ban on male nationals aged 18 to 60 leaving the country, an estimated 600,000 to 850,000 Ukrainian men still managed to flee to Europe.

What were the main groups evading the draft in the US during the Civil War?

During the American Civil War, draft evaders were most numerous among poor Irish immigrants in the North. In the South, evaders were most common in hill country and specific regions of Texas, Louisiana, and Georgia.

What was the impact of the New York City draft riots in 1863?

The anti-draft riots in New York City in 1863 were violent demonstrations that lasted several days, resulting in significant casualties, including up to 120 deaths and 2,000 injuries, highlighting the intense resistance to conscription.

How did the Selective Service Act of 1917 address issues from the Civil War draft?

The Selective Service Act of 1917 was designed to remedy defects in the Civil War draft by allowing exemptions for dependency, essential occupations, and religious scruples, while prohibiting the purchase of exemptions or the use of substitutions.

What was the estimated rate of draft evasion in the US during World War I?

During World War I, it is estimated that nearly 11 percent of the draft-eligible population in the US refused to register or report for induction, and about 12 percent of draftees either failed to report to training camps or deserted.

What was the proportion of draft-eligible men in the US who were deferred or exempted during the Vietnam War?

During the Vietnam War, more than half of the 27 million men eligible for the draft were deferred, exempted, or disqualified, partly due to the large Baby Boomer cohort and the availability of student deferments.

What was the scale of draft offenses and convictions during the Vietnam War era in the US?

During the Vietnam era, approximately 570,000 young men were classified as draft offenders, and about 210,000 were formally accused of violations. However, only a small fraction, around 8,750, were convicted, and just 3,250 were jailed.

What role did draft counseling groups play during the Vietnam War in the US?

Draft counseling groups, often connected to national organizations like the American Friends Service Committee or Students for a Democratic Society, provided support and guidance to potential draft evaders. Specially trained individuals often served as counselors for these groups.

What was 'The Resistance' organization in the US anti-war movement during the Vietnam War, and what was its symbol?

'The Resistance' was a prominent organization that spearheaded draft resistance during the Vietnam War. It encouraged civil disobedience, such as burning draft cards or refusing induction, aiming to end the war and the draft system, often leading members to face imprisonment.

What impact did American draft evaders have on Canadian society after relocating?

American draft evaders who relocated to Canada during the Vietnam War often became prominent in Canadian arts and academia, contributing to the cultural scene and pushing politics leftward. While initially controversial for some Canadians, the government eventually welcomed them, and draft evasion was not a criminal offense in Canada.

What did James Fallows argue was the dominant factor in who fought versus who evaded the draft during the Vietnam War?

James Fallows argued that social class, rather than conscience or political conviction, was the primary factor determining who served in the Vietnam War and who evaded their obligation. He felt shame realizing that his evasion, aided by sophisticated counselors, meant working-class individuals from Boston would fight in his place.

How did Howard Zinn and Tom Hayden view draft evasion in relation to democracy?

Howard Zinn and Tom Hayden considered certain forms of draft evasion to be a positive expression of democracy, suggesting it reflected individual resistance to unjust government policies.

What concerns did ancient Greek playwrights have regarding draft evasion and its impact on democracy?

According to scholar Mathew R. Christ, ancient Greek playwrights were concerned that ongoing draft evasion in democratic Athens could have corrosive effects on democracy and community. They often emphasized the moral imperative for individuals to support their community and serve the common good.

What extreme measures did Ted Nugent reportedly take to avoid the Vietnam War draft?

Ted Nugent reportedly took extreme measures to avoid the draft, including consuming crystal meth and defecating in his pants before his physical examination, as stated in a 1970s High Times article and a 1990 newspaper interview.

How did Bernie Sanders navigate the draft system after his conscientious objector status was denied?

After graduating college, Bernie Sanders applied for conscientious objector status, though he was not religious. His application was denied, but a series of hearings and delays extended his eligibility until he was too old to be drafted, a process that took him to age 26.

What was the reason given for Donald Trump's medical deferment from the Vietnam War draft?

Donald Trump received a medical deferment from the Vietnam War draft due to a diagnosis of bone spurs in his heels, reportedly granted by a doctor who was a friend of his father.

What did Jimmy Carter's 1977 pardon for Vietnam War draft resisters entail?

In 1977, President Jimmy Carter issued a pardon offering unconditional amnesty to Vietnam War draft resisters who requested it. This move was controversial, with critics on the right arguing it lacked penalty and critics on the left noting it required admitting guilt.

According to Michael S. Foley, what type of draft evasion is considered effective in stopping wars or drafts?

Michael S. Foley argued that only public anti-draft activity, undertaken consciously and collectively, is relevant to stopping a draft or a war. He viewed many other forms of draft evasion as merely personally beneficial.

What did the 'Manual for Draft-Age Immigrants to Canada' suggest for draft evasion?

The 'Manual for Draft-Age Immigrants to Canada' suggested various methods for evading the draft, including feigning mental illness or physical ailments, and advised readers to consider the Nuremberg principles when making their draft decisions.

What were the key findings of literary critics regarding the memoirs of Vietnam War draft dodgers who went to Canada?

Literary critics noted that draft dodgers in these memoirs often denounced the state and resisted mass movements, contradicting stereotypes of them being unthinking followers or radicals. They also showed less interest in romantic love, prioritizing immediate sexual urges, which aligned with Herbert Marcuse's ideas on the liberatory power of eros.

What was the significance of the term 'Zombies' in Canada during WWII?

During World War II in Canada, 'Zombies' was a pejorative nickname given to men conscripted under the National Resources Mobilization Act (NRMA) who were only obligated to serve within Canada, not overseas. They were seen as 'dead-to-life' or useless by those serving abroad.

What was the primary motivation for Syrian draft evaders fleeing the country after 2011?

The primary motivations for Syrian draft evaders fleeing the country after 2011 included fear of dying in the civil war, obeying parental wishes, and disgust with the government of Bashar al-Assad.

What was the historical context of 'purchasable military commutation' in Belgium?

In 19th-century Belgium, the practice of 'purchasable military commutation' allowed citizens to legally buy their way out of military draft. This system was criticized by some as a 'bastard form of equality' that favored the wealthy over the poor.

What was the nature of the draft evasion in Eritrea related to gender?

In Eritrea, mothers are typically excused from the draft. This policy has reportedly led to an increase in pregnancies among single women, as it serves as a method to evade mandatory military service.

Draft Evasion Wiki: The Unseen Path: Navigating the Draft Evasion Landscape

Dive in with Flashcard Learning!

When you are ready...
🎮 Play the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge Game🎮

Defining Draft Evasion

Core Concept

Draft evasion, or conscription evasion, refers to any successful attempt to elude a government-imposed obligation to serve in the nation's military forces. This often involves refusing to comply with military draft laws.

Historically, draft evasion has been a characteristic feature of conflicts where conscription is enforced, with legal frameworks against it dating back millennia.

Legal and Ethical Dimensions

Generally considered a criminal offense, draft evasion carries legal penalties. However, the motivations behind evasion are complex and varied, often stemming from deeply held personal, ethical, or political beliefs.

The term "draft dodger" is sometimes used pejoratively, though it can also be used neutrally or even as an honorific in specific contexts.

Evasion vs. Resistance

A distinction is often made between draft avoidance (legally obtaining deferments or exemptions) and draft resistance (overtly breaking laws or communicating conscious opposition). Draft resisters often reject the categorization of their actions as mere evasion, viewing them as a confrontation with the system.

While both are forms of non-compliance, resistance typically involves a public stance or direct challenge to government policy.

Methods of Evasion and Resistance

Legal Avoidance

Many individuals seek to legally circumvent conscription by adhering strictly to draft laws to obtain deferments or exemptions. Common methods include:

Claiming conscientious objector status based on sincere religious or ethical beliefs.
Obtaining student deferments by pursuing education.
Securing medical or psychological deferments if genuine health issues exist.
Utilizing legal exemptions based on dependency or essential civilian occupations.
Not being selected through a draft lottery system.

Circumventing the Law

More illicit methods involve circumventing, manipulating, or violating the spirit of draft laws. These practices are often private and unpublicized:

Feigning or exaggerating medical or psychological conditions.
Obtaining fraudulent deferments or exemptions through bribery or influence.
Self-inflicted injuries or deliberate failure on intelligence tests.
Falsely claiming protected status (e.g., homosexuality, where excluded by military policy).

Overt Resistance

Draft resistance involves open defiance and lawbreaking, often as a public statement against government policy or war:

Declining to register for the draft or report for induction.
Publicly burning or turning in draft cards.
Living "underground" to avoid apprehension.
Emigrating to another country to escape conscription or trial.
Organizing or participating in anti-draft demonstrations or riots.
Supporting or aiding other draft evaders.

Global Perspectives on Evasion

United States: Historical Context

The U.S. has a long history of draft evasion, notably during the Civil War, World War I, the Korean War, and particularly the Vietnam War. Methods ranged from legal deferments for students and conscientious objectors to more illicit means like feigning illness or emigration.

The Vietnam War era saw significant resistance, with hundreds of thousands accused of draft offenses, highlighting societal divisions and opposition to the conflict.

Canada: Sanctuary and Support

During the Vietnam War, Canada became a destination for many American draft evaders. While draft evasion itself was not a criminal offense in Canada, deserters faced a more complex situation. Canadian support groups provided counseling and assistance to arriving evaders.

The presence of these emigrants influenced Canadian society, contributing to its arts and academic scenes and pushing its politics leftward.

Russia & Soviet Union: Endemic Evasion

Draft evasion has been a persistent issue in Russia and the Soviet Union, particularly during the Soviet-Afghan War. Reports suggest that evasion was "endemic," with elites often bribing their way out of service.

In contemporary Russia, evasion remains widespread, with a significant percentage of eligible men reportedly avoiding service. The ongoing conflict in Ukraine has further exacerbated this, leading to mass emigration to avoid mobilization.

Israel: Societal Integration and Resistance

Israel's mandatory military draft is deeply integrated into society. While legal exemptions exist for specific groups, draft evasion and refusal have seen increases, particularly among young men and certain segments of the population.

Notable resistance movements and individual acts of refusal highlight ongoing debates about military service, pacifism, and political conscience within Israeli society.

Broader Implications and Debates

Effectiveness of Evasion

Scholars debate the effectiveness of draft evasion in achieving its goals, such as ending wars or dismantling conscription systems. Some argue that only collective, public resistance significantly impacts policy.

Others contend that the cumulative effect of numerous individual acts of evasion, even if private, can exert substantial economic and political pressure on states, potentially leading to systemic change.

Social Class and Privilege

A significant issue raised is the role of social class in draft evasion. Historically, individuals from privileged backgrounds often had greater access to legal deferments, resources for evasion, or means to emigrate.

This disparity has led to accusations of class discrimination, where working-class individuals disproportionately bear the burden of military service, fueling resentment and further resistance.

Democracy and Civic Duty

The practice of draft evasion intersects with concepts of democracy, civic duty, and individual conscience. Some view evasion as a legitimate expression of dissent and a check on state power.

Conversely, concerns are raised about the potential corrosive effects of widespread evasion on social cohesion, respect for law, and the perceived fairness of democratic institutions.

Related Concepts

Conscientious Objection

A key form of draft avoidance, conscientious objection is the refusal to participate in war or military service based on moral or religious grounds. Objectors may be required to perform alternative civilian service.

Desertion

Military desertion involves unlawfully absenting oneself from duty. While distinct from draft evasion (which occurs before or during induction), it represents a similar rejection of military obligation and can carry severe penalties.

War Resistance

A broader term encompassing various forms of opposition to war, including draft evasion, anti-war activism, and civil disobedience. It reflects a commitment to peace and a rejection of militarism.

Teacher's Corner

Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio

Edit and Print Materials from this study in the wiki2web studio

Click here to open the "Draft Evasion" Wiki2Web Studio curriculum kit

Use the free Wiki2web Studio to generate printable flashcards, worksheets, exams, and export your materials as a web page or an interactive game.

True or False?

Test Your Knowledge!

Gamer's Corner

Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?

Learn about draft_evasion while playing the wiki2web Clarity Challenge game.

Unlock the mystery image and prove your knowledge by earning trophies. This simple game is addictively fun and is a great way to learn!

Play now

Explore More Topics

Discover other topics to study!

permanent magnet motor

healthcare reform in the united states

megadiverse countries

five eyes

obsessive–compulsive disorder

violin

polish people's party 1945–1949

canoe polo

roman temple

yale university

References

"Muisti: MetsÃ¤kaartilaiset. TV1 torstaina 20.4.2017 " (11 October 2015). Finnish-language website. Retrieved 10 February 2018.

"HitleriÃ¤ vastaan sodittiin Suomessa hajanaisesti. Ajankohtainen Kakkonen" (13 February 2013). Finnish-language website. Retrieved 10 February 2018.

Kirk (8 April 2014), p. 8 (citing figures from the United Nations Commission on Human Rights).

Khan, Adnan R. (4 April 2016). "Not Quite Tragic Enough". Maclean's, pp. 27â28. Retrieved 19 October 2018.

Rothenberg, Leslie S. (1968). The Draft and You: A Handbook on the Selective Service System. New York: Anchor Books / Doubleday, p. 221. No ISBN.

Cortright (2005), cited above, p. 165 (quoting task force chair Martin Anderson).

Burns, John (11 October 1967). "Deaf to the Draft". The Globe and Mail (Toronto), pp. 1, 2.

Clausen, Oliver (21 May 1967). "Boys Without a Country". The New York Times Magazine, pp. 25 and 94â105.

Adams, James (20 October 2007). "'The Big Guys Keep Being Surprised by Us.'" The Globe and Mail (Toronto), p. R6 (statting that "close to 100,000" had been sold).

McGill (2017), cited above, pp. 172â181 ("The Alternative America in Draft-Dodger Novels" sub-chapter).

Beelaert, Amy M. (November 1993). "Voices of Our Times: I Refuse: Memories of a Vietnam War Objector". The English Journal, vol. 82, no. 7, p. 84.

Peters, Pamela J. (April 1992). "I Refuse: Memories of a Vietnam War Objector", Library Journal, vol. 117, no. 6, p. 129.

Macfarlane, David (30 April 1994). "Fetherling's Talents Take Wing". The Globe and Mail, p. C20.

Ware, Randall (1 May 1994). "A Grey Memoir of a Colorful Time". Ottawa Citizen, p. B3.

Grady, Wayne (8 October 2008). "An Artful Dodger". The Globe and Mail, p. D4.

Christ (2006), cited above, pp. 65â87 ("Conscription and Draft Evasion through a Tragic Lens" section).

A full list of references for this article are available at the Draft evasion Wikipedia page

Feedback & Support

To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.

Disclaimer

Important Notice

This page was generated by an Artificial Intelligence and is intended for informational and educational purposes only. The content is based on a snapshot of publicly available data from Wikipedia and may not be entirely accurate, complete, or up-to-date.

This is not legal advice. The information provided on this website is not a substitute for professional legal consultation, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of a qualified legal professional with any questions you may have regarding conscription laws or draft obligations. Never disregard professional legal advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website.

The creators of this page are not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for any actions taken based on the information provided herein.

The Unseen Path

💡 Dive in with Flashcard Learning! 💡

Defining Draft Evasion ℹ️

📜 Core Concept

⚖️ Legal and Ethical Dimensions

🤝 Evasion vs. Resistance

Methods of Evasion and Resistance 🛠️

✅ Legal Avoidance

⚠️ Circumventing the Law

✊ Overt Resistance

Global Perspectives on Evasion 🌐

🇺🇸 United States: Historical Context

🇨🇦 Canada: Sanctuary and Support

🇷🇺 Russia & Soviet Union: Endemic Evasion

🇮🇱 Israel: Societal Integration and Resistance

Broader Implications and Debates 🤔

📈 Effectiveness of Evasion

👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Social Class and Privilege

🏛️ Democracy and Civic Duty

Related Concepts 🔗

🕊️ Conscientious Objection

🚶 Desertion

✊ War Resistance

Teacher's Corner 🧑‍🏫

Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio

True or False? 🤔

❓ Test Your Knowledge! ❓

Gamer's Corner 🎮

Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?

Explore More Topics

📜 Discover other topics to study!

References

📜 References

Feedback & Support 👍

To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.

Disclaimer ⚠️

📜 Important Notice

Dive in with Flashcard Learning!

Defining Draft Evasion

Core Concept

Legal and Ethical Dimensions

Evasion vs. Resistance

Methods of Evasion and Resistance

Legal Avoidance

Circumventing the Law

Overt Resistance

Global Perspectives on Evasion

United States: Historical Context

Canada: Sanctuary and Support

Russia & Soviet Union: Endemic Evasion

Israel: Societal Integration and Resistance

Broader Implications and Debates

Effectiveness of Evasion

Social Class and Privilege

Democracy and Civic Duty

Related Concepts

Conscientious Objection

Desertion

War Resistance

Teacher's Corner

True or False?

Test Your Knowledge!

Gamer's Corner

Discover other topics to study!

References

Feedback & Support

Disclaimer

Important Notice