The Global Tapestry
An academic journey into the intricate dynamics of cultural coexistence, policy, and societal impact across the globe.
What is it? 👇 Explore Policies 🏛️Dive in with Flashcard Learning!
🎮 Play the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge Game🎮
Defining Multiculturalism
Coexistence of Cultures
Multiculturalism fundamentally refers to the coexistence of multiple distinct cultures within a single societal framework. In sociological discourse and common parlance, it often serves as a descriptor for ethnic or cultural pluralism, where diverse ethnic and cultural groups inhabit a shared society. This phenomenon can manifest in mixed ethnic community areas or across an entire nation, frequently focusing on the interplay between indigenous populations and settler-descended groups.
Processes of Emergence
From a sociological perspective, multiculturalism represents an end-state resulting from either organic societal evolution or deliberate processes, such as legally regulated immigration. On a national scale, it can arise from migration flows, both legal and illegal. Within a nation, it might be artificially created when administrative areas with distinct cultures are merged, as exemplified by the historical context of French and English Canada.
A Political Philosophy
In the realm of political science, multiculturalism denotes a state's capacity to effectively manage cultural plurality within its sovereign borders. As a political philosophy, it encompasses a broad spectrum of ideologies and policies. It is often conceptualized using metaphors like a "salad bowl" or a "cultural mosaic," which emphasize the retention of distinct cultural identities, in contrast to the "melting pot" analogy, which implies complete assimilation.
Historical Trajectories
Ancient Roots of Diversity
The notion that contemporary societies are uniquely diverse is often a misconception. Historical migration patterns have frequently led to levels of diversity comparable to, or even exceeding, those observed today. For instance, European nations like the United Kingdom, France, Germany, and the Netherlands have long histories of diverse societies shaped by colonial migration, labor migration, and refugee movements. States embodying multicultural ideals, such as the Achaemenid Empire under Cyrus the Great, practiced policies of cultural incorporation and tolerance in ancient times.
European Evolution
Historically, Europe was characterized by immense ethnic, linguistic, and religious diversity, far surpassing its current number of nation-states. Local and regional identities were robust, each with unique dialects, customs, and traditions. The rise of larger nation-states from the 16th century onward, particularly after the French Revolution and into the 19th century, initiated a process of cultural homogenization. Governments actively promoted national identities through education, conscription, and language standardization, leading to the decline of regional languages and dialects. The Habsburg monarchy, existing from 1282 to 1918, notably resisted this trend, maintaining a mosaic of languages, religions, and regional identities.
The American Experience
In the 19th century, the United States experienced massive immigration from diverse ethnic and religious backgrounds, including Irish, Italian, Chinese, German, and Jewish communities. This influx led to the concept of the "melting pot," a metaphor suggesting that immigrant cultures would blend and amalgamate without direct state intervention, with individuals and groups assimilating at their own pace. This differs from modern multiculturalism, which does not necessarily entail complete assimilation. At the turn of the 20th century, the US immigrant population percentage was comparable to current levels, highlighting a long history of diversity.
Modern Government Policy
Canada's Pioneering Role
Multiculturalism became an official policy in several Western nations starting in the 1970s, driven by various factors including the increasing cultural mosaic of major Western cities. The Canadian government is frequently cited as a key instigator of multicultural ideology due to its public emphasis on the social importance of immigration. The Canadian Royal Commission on Bilingualism and Biculturalism is often considered the origin of modern political awareness of multiculturalism. Canada adopted multiculturalism as official national policy in 1971, followed by Australia in 1973, a policy they maintain today.
European Shifts
While some Western nations embraced multiculturalism, several right-of-center governments in the European Union, notably the Netherlands and Denmark, have reversed national policies, returning to an official monoculturalism. Similar debates about the success of multicultural policies and concerns over "home-grown" terrorism and incipient segregation have emerged in the United Kingdom. Leaders such as David Cameron, Angela Merkel, John Howard, José María Aznar, and Nicolas Sarkozy have voiced doubts regarding the effectiveness of multicultural policies in integrating immigrants.
Global Variations
Many nation-states in Africa, Asia, and the Americas are descriptively multicultural due to their inherent cultural diversity. In these contexts, ethnic communalism can be a significant political concern. The policies adopted by these states may parallel Western multiculturalist approaches, but their historical backgrounds differ, and their ultimate goal might be mono-cultural or mono-ethnic nation-building, as seen in Malaysia's ambition to create a unified 'Malaysian race' by 2020.
Research on Societal Impact
Diversity and Social Cohesion
Contemporary research, as highlighted by migration researcher Hein de Haas, indicates no systematic correlation between levels of immigration or ethnic diversity and social cohesion or trust. Instead, factors such as economic inequality and trust in government are found to be far more critical for maintaining social cohesion. Countries like Canada and Australia, despite high levels of immigration and diversity, demonstrate stable and well-functioning societies due to low income inequality and strong governmental trust. Conversely, political hate speech targeting minority groups can significantly diminish social cohesion, suggesting that diversity itself is not the undermining factor.
Trust and Engagement
A notable 2007 study by Harvard professor Robert D. Putnam, surveying 26,200 individuals across 40 American communities, found that increased racial diversity correlated with a greater loss of trust, even after adjusting for socioeconomic factors. Putnam observed that people in diverse communities tended to "hunker down," exhibiting less trust in local authorities, media, and even their neighbors. He famously stated, "The effect of diversity is worse than had been imagined. And it's not just that we don't trust people who are not like us. In diverse communities, we don't trust people who do not look like us." However, Putnam also posited that this "allergy to diversity" is likely to diminish over time, leading to long-term cultural, economic, and developmental benefits, and affirmed the substantial benefits of diversity to society.
Public Goods and Democracy
Ethnologist Frank Salter, in his 2003 book *On Genetic Interests*, argued that relatively homogeneous societies tend to invest more in public goods, indicating higher levels of public altruism. He cited correlations between ethnic homogeneity and government share of GDP, as well as average citizen wealth, and noted that multi-ethnic societies were less charitable and less effective in cooperating for public infrastructure. However, research psychologist Kenan Malik criticized Salter's views, arguing for insufficient attention to historical context and suggesting that observed favoritism towards co-ethnics is better explained by cultural factors. Other research presents conflicting findings, with some studies suggesting ethnic diversity is not detrimental to peace, public goods provision, or democracy, and can even advance disadvantaged students. A 2018 study in the *American Political Science Review* and a 2015 study in the *American Journal of Sociology* specifically challenged earlier findings linking ethnoracial homogeneity to greater public goods or racial diversity to adverse effects on trust.
Arguments for Support
A Fairer, More Tolerant System
Supporters view multiculturalism as a more equitable societal framework, enabling individuals to authentically express their identities within a tolerant environment that is better equipped to address social challenges. They contend that culture is not a monolithic entity defined by a single race or religion, but rather a dynamic outcome of multiple evolving factors. This perspective emphasizes the fluidity and adaptability of cultural identity in a changing world.
Combating Historical Injustice
Modern support for multiculturalism largely emerged from post-World War II societal transformations, particularly the "human rights revolution." The atrocities of institutionalized racism and ethnic cleansing, starkly revealed by the Holocaust, became undeniable. Concurrently, the collapse of European colonial systems and the rise of civil rights movements in the United States exposed and challenged discriminatory practices and assimilationist ideals. In this historical context, multiculturalism in Western nations was seen as a vital tool to combat racism, protect minority communities, and rectify policies that had historically denied minorities full access to the freedoms and equalities promised by Enlightenment liberalism.
Critical Perspectives
Sustainability and Desirability
Critics frequently question the sustainability, inherent paradoxes, or even the desirability of the multicultural ideal, which envisions benignly coexisting cultures that interact and influence one another while remaining distinct. A common argument is that nation-states, traditionally associated with a unique cultural identity, may suffer from enforced multiculturalism, leading to the erosion of the host nation's distinct culture.
Challenges to Universalism
Sarah Song posits that cultures are historically shaped by their members and, due to globalization, lack rigid boundaries, suggesting they are more resilient than some critics assume. She argues against the notion of special rights, viewing cultures as mutually constructive and influenced by the dominant culture. Brian Barry advocates for a "difference-blind" approach in the political sphere, rejecting group-based rights as antithetical to the universalist liberal project, which he grounds in individual rights. Susan Moller Okin, a feminist political philosopher, raised concerns in 1999 that the principle of cultural equality could lead to severe violations of women's equal rights.
Social Cohesion and Conflict
Former Colorado Governor Dick Lamm argued that "diverse peoples worldwide are mostly engaged in hating each other—that is, when they are not killing each other. A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent." American classicist Victor Davis Hanson rejected multiculturalism, asserting the superiority of Western culture. In New Zealand, officially a bi-cultural nation, multiculturalism has been perceived by some Māori as a threat, an attempt by the government to undermine Māori demands for self-determination and encourage assimilation. Furthermore, far-right sympathizers have increasingly engaged in online campaigns against multicultural advertisements by global brands, reflecting a growing opposition to diversity in public representation.
Multiculturalism in the Americas
Argentina: A Welcoming Nation
Argentina's constitution explicitly promotes immigration and recognizes multiple citizenships, reflecting a high level of multiculturalism in its national culture. Despite 97% of its population identifying as European descent and mestizo, the country actively supports foreign festivals and cultural expressions, including their dissemination through diverse media. Regional languages such as Guaraní in Corrientes, Quechua in Santiago del Estero, and Qom, Mocoví, and Wichí in Chaco are officially recognized. The National Institute for Indigenous Affairs reports 1,779 registered indigenous communities belonging to 39 indigenous peoples, underscoring Argentina's rich cultural mosaic.
Bolivia: Indigenous Majority
Bolivia stands out as a highly diverse nation, home to 36 distinct indigenous groups, which constitute over 62% of its population, making it the most indigenous country in Latin America. The Aymara and Quechua are the largest among these groups, alongside a 30% mestizo population of mixed European and indigenous ancestry. Bolivia's political administrations have embraced multicultural politics, with its 2009 Constitution enshrining multicultural principles and recognizing 36 official languages in addition to Spanish, each linked to its own culture and indigenous group. Bolivian culture is a vibrant blend of Aymara, Quechua, Spanish, and other Latin American influences.
Brazil: A Mixed Heritage
Brazil is recognized for its multiculturalism, though its definition remains a subject of discussion. While the Harvard Institute of Economic Research highlights Brazil's large mixed-race population, the University of Oldenburg notes that nearly all Brazilians speak Portuguese. Major cities like São Paulo host migrants from Japan, Italy, Lebanon, Portugal, and Africa, showcasing a prevalent multicultural presence throughout the country. Brazil has made significant strides in embracing migrant cultures, increasing awareness and actively combating anti-blackness, although school engagement in these matters still requires further development.
Mexico: Ancient and Modern Diversity
Mexico has a long history as a multicultural country, shaped by the Spanish conquest, which influenced indigenous religion, politics, culture, and ethnicity. The Spanish language became dominant, and the mestizo identity emerged from the blend of Indigenous and Spanish heritage. Mexico City has shown rapid integration, performing well in the Intercultural Cities Index. The country is ethnically diverse, with a population of approximately 123 million (2017), comprising Mestizos, White Mexicans, Indigenous Mexicans, and other groups like Arab, Afro, and Asian Mexicans. From 2000 to 2010, the foreign-born population doubled, primarily from Guatemala and the United States, contributing to Mexico's "melting pot" character. Its status as a "cradle of civilization" further influences its multiculturalism, integrating diverse civilizational influences and adapting cultural traditions from immigrants into its unique mestizaje.
Peru: A Confluence of Peoples
Peru exemplifies multiculturalism, with a population of 31 million (2016) and diverse communities shaped by its borders with Ecuador, Colombia, Brazil, Chile, and Bolivia. Following the Spanish Conquest, African and Asian peoples were brought as slaves, contributing to a rich mix of ethnic groups. Today, Amerindians constitute 25.8% of the population, Mestizos 60.2%, White 5.9%, and Black, Chinese, Japanese, and other groups 4.8%. Early policies, such as President José de San Martín's initiatives in 1821, granted foreigners freedom to establish industries and facilitated naturalization, fostering a welcoming environment for diverse populations.
United States: A Complex Mosaic
While the United States does not have an official federal multiculturalism policy, ethnic and cultural diversity is a pervasive feature across its rural, suburban, and urban landscapes. Continuous mass immigration since the 19th century has been central to the US economy and society, fostering the "melting pot" metaphor, which implies a blending of immigrant cultures without state intervention. This differs from multiculturalism's emphasis on retaining distinct identities. The concept of cultural pluralism, from which modern multiculturalism emerged, was developed by pragmatist philosophers and early sociologists in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, including figures like William James and W. E. B. Du Bois. Educational approaches to multiculturalism have extended to grade school curricula, aiming to represent diverse student populations. However, the US has also faced challenges, including domestic terrorism with diverse ideological perpetrators, and debates over the impact of diversity on civic engagement, as highlighted by Robert Putnam's findings on short-term trust decline, alongside his acknowledgment of long-term benefits.
Venezuela: Blended Identities
Venezuela, with an estimated population of 32 million (2018), is characterized by a rich variety of ethnic groups, approximately 68% of whom are mestizo, indicating a mixed-race heritage. Venezuelan culture is primarily a blend of indigenous, Spanish, and African influences. The Spanish conquest profoundly shaped its religion, language, and traditions, while African influences are evident in its music. Despite Spanish being the main language, over 40 indigenous languages are still spoken today, reflecting the nation's enduring cultural diversity.
Colombia: A Tapestry of Origins
Colombia, with an estimated population of 51 million, is home to a wide array of ethnic groups. Approximately 49% of its population is Mestizo, 37% White, 10% of African descent, 3.4% Indigenous, and 0.6% Romani. A significant portion, 18.8 million Colombians, are direct descendants of Europeans, primarily from Spain, Italy, Germany, Poland, and England. The country also boasts the second-largest Arab diaspora in Latin America, with over 3.2 million descendants, mainly from Syria, Lebanon, and Palestine, further enriching its multicultural fabric.
Multiculturalism in Europe
Historical Context and Nationalism
Europe has always been a complex blend of Latin, Slavic, Germanic, Uralic, Celtic, Hellenic, Illyrian, Thracian, and other cultures, further influenced by Jewish, Christian, and Muslim belief systems. Despite the unifying overlay of Imperial Roman Christianity, significant geographic and cultural differences persisted from antiquity into the modern era. The 19th century saw the ideology of nationalism transform the concept of the state, leading to the formation of new nation-states founded on the principle that each nation deserved its own sovereignty and the preservation of its unique culture and history. This often resulted in policies promoting cultural homogeneity, including compulsory primary education in national languages, standardization of languages, and, in some cases, violent cultural assimilation or ethnic cleansing.
Bulgaria: A Legacy of Tolerance
Since its establishment in the seventh century, Bulgaria has been a host to numerous religions, ethnic groups, and nations. Its capital, Sofia, is unique in Europe for having four major places of worship—Eastern Orthodox, Islam, Roman Catholicism, and Orthodox Judaism—peacefully coexisting within 300 meters of each other, a phenomenon dubbed "The Square of Religious Tolerance." This historical context of coexistence is cited as a key reason for Bulgaria's success in saving its entire 48,000-strong Jewish population from Nazi concentration camps during World War II. Bulgaria serves as a regional example for multiculturalism, with its largest ethnic minority groups, Turks and Roma, enjoying significant political representation, including mayors, parliamentary deputies, and ministerial positions.
France: Republicanism and Diversity
Post-World War II, France experienced a significant increase in immigration from Europe, the Americas, Africa, and Asia, driven by labor needs for reconstruction. This included waves of Vietnamese migrants after 1954 and a substantial increase in Algerian immigrants following the Algerian War. Multiculturalism in France has faced considerable resistance, particularly in education, where it was often seen as a threat to traditional French culture. Debates among elites reveal three main positions: traditionalists who insist on historic republican principles of "laïcité" (secularism), modernizing republicans who accept some cultural pluralism, and multiculturalist republicans who envision a pluralist French identity. The 2003 Stasi Report, for instance, denounced "Islamism" as opposed to French culture, leading to regulations against religious symbols like the hijab in schools, though gestures toward multiculturalism, such as government-contracted Muslim schools, also exist.
Germany: Integration Debates
In October 2010, German Chancellor Angela Merkel declared that attempts to build a multicultural society in Germany had "utterly failed," stating that the concept of living side-by-side without integration "does not work." She emphasized that immigrants should integrate and adopt Germany's culture and values, a sentiment she reiterated in 2015, criticizing multiculturalism for leading to "parallel societies." This stance fueled ongoing debates in Germany regarding immigration levels, their impact, and the integration of Middle Eastern immigrants. Despite these criticisms, the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community of Germany has been granted "corporation under public law status," placing it on par with major Christian and Jewish communities.
Luxembourg: A Highly Diverse State
Luxembourg boasts one of Europe's highest foreign-born populations, with nearly half of its total residents being foreigners. Comprising 170 different nationalities, 86% of whom are of European descent (primarily from Belgium, France, Italy, Germany, and Portugal), Luxembourg is a truly diverse nation. Its official languages—German, French, and Luxembourgish—are all supported within the government and education system. In 2005, Luxembourg officially endorsed and implemented the objectives of the UNESCO Convention on the Protection and Promotion of the Diversity of Cultural Expressions, affirming its multicultural policies and fostering political awareness of cultural diversity.
Netherlands: From Pluralism to Assimilation
Multiculturalism in the Netherlands emerged with significant immigration increases in the mid-1950s and 1960s, leading to the adoption of an official national policy in the early 1980s. This policy allowed different groups to manage their religious and cultural affairs, while the state handled housing and work. The 1990s saw optimism regarding immigration, with expectations that multicultural policies would reduce socioeconomic disparities. However, public opinion shifted towards assimilationist policies from 1994 onwards. Following the September 11 attacks and high-profile murders in the Netherlands, political debate intensified. In 2011, the First Rutte cabinet announced a departure from multiculturalism, asserting that "Dutch culture, norms and values must be dominant."
Romania: Enduring Diversity
Since antiquity, Romania has been home to a multitude of religious and ethnic groups, including Roma, Hungarians, Germans, Turks, Greeks, Tatars, Slovaks, Serbs, and Jews. While many emigrated during World War II and the Communist era, Romania has seen a growing influx of immigrants and refugees from the Arab world, Asia, and Africa since the 1990s. This trend is expected to continue as Romanian workers increasingly seek opportunities abroad, leading to their replacement by foreign labor. This ongoing demographic shift continues to shape Romania's diverse cultural landscape.
Scandinavia: Varied Approaches
Multiculturalism in Scandinavia has sparked discussions around marriage, dress, religious schools, Muslim funeral rites, and gender equality, with differing policies and responses across Denmark, Sweden, and Norway regarding issues like forced marriages. Sweden, having experienced a greater share of non-Western immigration since the early 1970s, was the first European country to adopt an official multiculturalism policy. In 1975, a unanimous Swedish parliament passed an act rejecting ethnic homogeneity and assimilation, promoting equality, partnership, and freedom of choice for minority groups to retain their languages and cultures. Despite opposition from parties like the Sweden Democrats, multiculturalism remains official policy. However, studies indicate that a minority of Swedes desire to live in culturally diverse areas, and social trust is lower in regions with high levels of non-Nordic immigration, particularly from culturally distant countries.
Serbia: Vojvodina's Diversity
Serbia officially recognizes 19 ethnic groups as national minorities. Vojvodina, an autonomous province in northern Serbia, is particularly known for its multiethnic and multicultural identity, hosting over 26 ethnic groups and boasting six official languages. The largest ethnic groups include Serbs (67%), Hungarians (13%), Slovaks, Croats, Romani, Romanians, Montenegrins, Bunjevci, Bosniaks, and Rusyns. Significant immigrant minorities include Chinese and Arabs. Radio Television of Vojvodina broadcasts programs in ten local languages, and the provincial government's "Promotion of Multiculturalism and Tolerance in Vojvodina" project, initiated in 2005, aims to foster cultural diversity and interethnic tolerance. Serbia continues to work on improving minority inclusion as part of its efforts to gain full accession to the European Union.
United Kingdom: Policy Evolution
Multicultural policies were adopted by local administrations in the UK from the 1970s and 1980s, with the Labour government committing to a national multiculturalist approach in 1997. However, a significant backlash emerged after 2001, leading to a shift towards policies of "community cohesion." In 2011, Conservative Prime Minister David Cameron declared that "state multiculturalism has failed." Critics argue that analyses portraying society as "too diverse" for social democracy and cohesion can have "performative" effects, potentially legitimizing racism against immigrants. Conversely, some, like journalist Ed West, critique the very notion of the UK as a multicultural society, viewing the project of diversity as misguided.
Russian Federation: Nationality and Territory
The concept of multiculturalism in Russia is deeply intertwined with its vast territory and the Soviet notion of "nationality." The Russian Federation is structured into a series of republics, each granting a predominant ethnic group significant autonomy in determining local laws. A distinction is made between *Rossiyane* (Russian citizens) and *Russkie* (ethnic Russians). Within their respective territories, various peoples have the right to practice their customs, traditions, and even impose their own laws, as seen in Chechnya, provided these do not violate federal and constitutional laws of the Russian Federation.
Multiculturalism in Asia
India: A Subcontinental Mosaic
India, a nation with a profound and ancient history, unique geography, and diverse demography, is home to an astonishing 1652 indigenous languages (as per the 1961 Census). Its culture is a rich amalgamation of diverse sub-cultures spread across the Indian subcontinent, with languages, religions, dances, music, architecture, and customs varying significantly from place to place, yet possessing a common thread. The historical Indian caste system, defining social classes by thousands of endogamous hereditary groups, has shaped its social stratification. Religiously, Hindus form the majority (79.8%), followed by Muslims (14.2%), Christians (2.3%), Sikhs (1.7%), Buddhists (0.7%), Jains (0.4%), and others. Linguistically, the country is dominated by Indo-Aryan and Dravidian families, with Sino-Tibetan and Austroasiatic languages in the northeast. India officially follows a three-language policy (Hindi, English, and a state official language), and its state boundaries are largely drawn based on linguistic groups, preserving local ethno-linguistic sub-cultures. However, India has also experienced religiously motivated violence and challenges for disadvantaged communities in public employment, housing, and inter-marriages.
Indonesia: Unity in Diversity
Indonesia is a daily testament to pluralism, diversity, and multiculturalism, boasting over 600 ethnic groups (95% Native Indonesian), with the Javanese being the largest (nearly 42%). It is also home to more than 700 living languages and, while predominantly Muslim, has substantial Christian and Hindu populations. The national motto, *Bhinneka Tunggal Ika* ("Unity in Diversity"), enshrined in the national ideology Pancasila, articulates this rich diversity. The government actively nurtures and promotes local cultural diversity through a pluralist approach. Internal migration, including government transmigration programs, has led to significant populations of ethnic groups residing outside their traditional regions. However, these interactions have not always been harmonious, leading to inter-ethnic and inter-religious clashes, such as the Sambas riots (1999), Sampit conflict (2001), Poso riots (1998-2000), and Maluku sectarian conflict (1999-2002). Despite these challenges, Indonesia continues to strive for and maintain unity and intercultural harmony through its national adherence to Pancasila. Chinese Indonesians, the largest foreign-origin minority, have faced discrimination and forced assimilation policies (e.g., during the Suharto era) despite centuries of acculturation, due to their economic influence and questions of national loyalty.
Teacher's Corner
Edit and Print this course in the Wiki2Web Teacher Studio
Click here to open the "Multiculturalism" Wiki2Web Studio curriculum kit
Use the free Wiki2web Studio to generate printable flashcards, worksheets, exams, and export your materials as a web page or an interactive game.
True or False?
Test Your Knowledge!
Gamer's Corner
Are you ready for the Wiki2Web Clarity Challenge?
Unlock the mystery image and prove your knowledge by earning trophies. This simple game is addictively fun and is a great way to learn!
Play now
References
References
- Doris Griesser "DenkanstöÃe aus der Multikulti-Monarchie" in: Standard, 3 July 2012; Pieter M. Judson "The Habsburg Empire. A New History" (Harvard 2016); Christopher Clark "The Sleepwalkers" (New York 2012).
- Patricia Engelhorn "Wie Wien mit Meersicht: Ein Tag in der Hafenstadt Triest" In: NZZ 15 February 2020.
- Fact or fiction in the great UK immigration debate. workpermit.com. News. 26 April 2005. Retrieved: 21 October 2007.
- The Economist: The changing of the guard, 3 April 2003.
- Susanne Wessendorf, The multiculturalism backlash: European discourses, policies and practices, p. 35; accessed through Google Books, 12 February 2011.
- Paul C. Gorski, "A Brief History of Multicultural Education", EdChange.org, November 1999; accessed 12 February 2011.
- Brian Barry, Culture and Equality (Polity Press, 2001), p. 148.
- Hanson, Victor Davis Carnage and Culture: Landmark Battles in the Rise to Western Power, New York: Random House, 2001. p. 205
- Ley No. 6604 de la Provincia de Chaco, 28 July 2010, B.O., (9092)
- John Jay, First American Supreme Court Chief Justice, Federalist Paper No. 2
- Historians speak out against proposed Texas textbook changes Michael Birnbaum, 18 March 2010.
- The Culture Wars' New Front: U.S. History Classes in Texas, Stephanie Simon, 14 July 2009.
- Texas Conservatives Win Curriculum Change, James C. McKinley Jr., 12 March 2010.
- The Human Rights of Muslims in Bulgaria in Law and Politics since 1878, Bulgarian Helsinki Committee, 2003
- The Bulgarian state and Bulgarian Turks (to the mid-1930s until the early-1990s), Bulgarian Archive State Agency
- Jeremy Jennings, "Citizenship, Republicanism and Multiculturalism in Contemporary France," British Journal of Political Science (2000) 30#4 575â597.
- Jennifer A. Selby, "Islam in France reconfigured: Republican Islam in the 2010 Gerin report." Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs 31.3 (2011): 383â398.
- Sarah Krouse, "Piping Hot Gromperekichelcher, Only if You Pass the Sproochentest." WALL STREET JOURNAL, 19 January 2018, p.1
- The Progress Party's politics (In Norwegian) From the official website of the Progress Party (23 November 2014)
- "India â Caste". Encyclopædia Britannica Online.
- Kuoni â Far East, A world of difference. p. 88. Published 1999 by Kuoni Travel & JPM Publications
- Malaysia fury at EU envoy remarks, BBC News
- "Multiculturalism Likely to Prevail in Korea", Lee Hyo-sik, Korea Times, 24 December 2009
- Phillips, Jock (11 August 2015). "History of immigration". Te Ara: The Encyclopedia of New Zealand. Retrieved 2 June 2017.
- "Waitangi Tribunal claim â MÄori Language Week". Ministry for Culture and Heritage. July 2010. Retrieved 19 January 2011.
Feedback & Support
To report an issue with this page, or to find out ways to support the mission, please click here.
Disclaimer
Important Notice
This page was generated by an Artificial Intelligence and is intended for informational and educational purposes only. The content is based on a snapshot of publicly available data from Wikipedia and may not be entirely accurate, complete, or up-to-date.
This is not professional academic or political advice. The information provided on this website is not a substitute for in-depth academic research, expert sociological analysis, or political consultation. Always refer to primary sources, peer-reviewed literature, and consult with qualified professionals for specific research or policy needs. Never disregard professional academic or political insights because of something you have read on this website.
The creators of this page are not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for any actions taken based on the information provided herein.